But you admit that a smaller population means less national power and less market power, even if the population is highly educated and works high skilled job, right?
Singapore has a highly educated and skilled population, but it is not a world power by any means.
The only reason China can even think of success independent of the US is that it has a large population.
What, in your view would be the ideal population level for China?
I never said China population is too small. You cannot use Singapore as yardstick . Singapore natural position should be in Malaysia but because of rasicst Malaysian politic it not possible So she had to go on her own.
Singapore benefit a lot from it too because of insecurity many Indo and Malaysian chinese park their money in Singapore allowing it to invest in industry, port and education. Coupled with liberal open policy and liberal immigration, relatively competent civil ,allowed it to propel into the first world
Due to small geography and small population base the impact of this policy is immediate and striking
But China is continental size country with huge and disparate population hobbled by century of poor policy and neglect coupled with geopolitic animosity from western world
It is much more difficult situation to advanced economically Only DXP with his enlightened policy change the mind set of the Chinese and yes Singapore and Hongkong open his horizon and confirm that with right policy Chinese society can prosper. With he did is to allowed the Chinese to get rich and take the responsibility of their own life and retreat from interfering in the day to day life of chinese people
So chinese population size is both burden and blesses at the same time. China is actually 2 countries the easter seabord is close to the first world and the western part is more third world.In other word inbalance development They make huge effort to equalized it but it is not easy It will take generation to bring th the western part of the country to the level of eastern board.
I think the egregious Hukou system should be discarded It is one of the worst perpetrated injustice and unfair practise to the Chinese society They should discard it . But they met with high resistance form the large city due to burden on social service and tax.
They already started to dismantle it by allowing the migrant worker to migrate to 2nd and 3rd tier cities but still too slow. If implemented right it might get China second wind of prosperity if they are allowed to buy properties in the cities and get social service