Littoral Combat Ships (LCS)

dtulsa

Junior Member
I have to admit the RFI is bothe encouraging and confusing at the same time confusing as in the needs for area defense beyond Sea Ram ie. ESSM at a minimum discouraging from a range aspect 3000
 

Jeff Head

General
Registered Member
As for me it's no secret my favorites are from least to most 1.modified LCS (Saudi) version 2.Legend class may reqire little to much for modification 3. Type 26 has both range and size and designed for the exact requirement complete with mk41 VLS and 5 inch gun 5. MY favorite is the Franco Italian Fremm again meets and most likely would exceed requirement but if this is a beauty contest she would be the winner Any way we shall find out by Aug 24 what all companies have submitted proposals and that will probably be announced shortly thereafter just my 2 and 1/2 cents worth any thoughts there master Jura Forbin or mister Jeff
They could get a fully competent Freedom class frigate if they wanted, with the armament, sensors and endurance, as well as combat ready.

The Legend class could be built to the same.

I seriously doubt that they will use any outside source, either the UK FFG or the Talian.

I expect that they will end up doing the Freedom class thing...and if they do it right this time, I am okay with that. Biut it NEEDS:

16-32 VLS cells capable of ESSM, VLSUBRIC, SM-2, and LRASM and ASM.
1 x 5" gun
2 x Helo hanger
Decent bow and towed sonars
24 x Hellfire SR ASM
8 x AMS cannister, unless they use 32 VLS and dedicate 8 of them to some ASM.
6-8,000 mile range at 20 knots
30+ knot speed (to keep with the carriers)

These things are all necessary for a strong multi-mission frigate, and we should not settle for anything less.

Use the 28 LCS that they upgrade to take on the lower intensity missions, from escort duties in low intensity areas, to patrols and counter mine duties for the INdependence class.

Anyhow...we shall see what we get.
 

dtulsa

Junior Member
They could get a fully competent Freedom class frigate if they wanted, with the armament, sensors and endurance, as well as combat ready.

The Legend class could be built to the same.

I seriously doubt that they will use any outside source, either the UK FFG or the Talian.

I expect that they will end up doing the Freedom class thing...and if they do it right this time, I am okay with that. Biut it NEEDS:

16-32 VLS cells capable of ESSM, VLSUBRIC, SM-2, and LRASM and ASM.
1 x 5" gun
2 x Helo hanger
Decent bow and towed sonars
24 x Hellfire SR ASM
8 x AMS cannister, unless they use 32 VLS and dedicate 8 of them to some ASM.
6-8,000 mile range at 20 knots
30+ knot speed (to keep with the carriers)

These things are all necessary for a strong multi-mission frigate, and we should not settle for anything less.

Use the 28 LCS that they upgrade to take on the lower intensity missions, from escort duties in low intensity areas, to patrols and counter mine duties for the INdependence class.

Anyhow...we shall see what we get.
I think you are very close to being right Jeff I don't see the hell fire as a need on the frigate though just put them in LCS only
 

Jeff Head

General
Registered Member
I think you are very close to being right Jeff I don't see the hell fire as a need on the frigate though just put them in LCS only
I think the Hellfire is a good idea for the FFGs too.

The LCS can certainly use them...but the FFGs are going to necessarily go into the Littorals too, and they will need something lighter, but in sufficient quantity to take on the likes of Iranian, North Korean or other less capable navies who might be tempted to try swarming techniques against them,...and those 24 hellfires and their control do not take up that much room.

Anyhow, we shall see. I know if I was making the decision, they would have them for the reasons I just gave.
 
Sep 12, 2016
... OHP Frigates (EDIT hastily retired
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

so that LCSs could ... shine)

...
now

"The new Secretary of the Navy, Richard Spencer,
...
When asked if the recently decommissioned Perry Class Frigates could be brought back into the fleet, he didn’t hesitate.

“The OHP is a heck of a simple boat that has a beautiful mission and that’s a possibility and we should take a look at taking those out of mothballs,” he said."

source is NavyTimes
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

fortunately, that article first talks ships, and only than various Creatures in the part I didn't read so that I don't throw up ... I was careful after I had seen a picture of Mrs./Mr./Creature Manning recently

LOL I hope my post doesn't violate Creatures' rights, Jeff just delete it if inappropriate
 

dtulsa

Junior Member
Sep 12, 2016

now

"The new Secretary of the Navy, Richard Spencer,
...
When asked if the recently decommissioned Perry Class Frigates could be brought back into the fleet, he didn’t hesitate.

“The OHP is a heck of a simple boat that has a beautiful mission and that’s a possibility and we should take a look at taking those out of mothballs,” he said."

source is NavyTimes
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

fortunately, that article first talks ships, and only than various Creatures in the part I didn't read so that I don't throw up ... I was careful after I had seen a picture of Mrs./Mr./Creature Manning recently

LOL I hope my post doesn't violate Creatures' rights, Jeff just delete it if inappropriate
Good article bout the Perry's sad they weren't upgraded at all wonder bout the supposed recommission of some of them stands have not heard anything lately
 

Jeff Head

General
Registered Member
Good article bout the Perry's sad they weren't upgraded at all wonder bout the supposed recommission of some of them stands have not heard anything lately
Of all of those built by the US, almost all of them have either been:

Dismantled
Sunk
Transferred

Only 10 are left that are on hold for potential further military transfer.

So they could only recommission ten of them if they wanted to.

IMHO, given the money they would have to spend to modernize them...it is too few a return. We would do better to go ahead and design a new vessel, or use one of the designs already available (IE FFG Freedom of FFG Legend) and build 30 of those.
 
Last edited:

dtulsa

Junior Member
Of all of those built by the US, almost all of them have either been:

Dismantled
Sunk
Transferred

Only 10 are left that are on hold for potential further military transfer.

So they could only recommission ten of them if they wanted to.

IMHO, given the money they would have to spend to modernize them...it is too few a return. We would do better to go ahead and design a new vessel, or use one of the designs already available (IE FFG Freedom of FFG Legend) and build 30 of those.
I'm thinking the same thing as good as the Perry's were it is just a case of they have had their time in the sun
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I now read
NAVSEA: Navy Hybrid Path to 355-Ship Fleet Could Only Take 10 to 15 Years
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

and inside
NAVSEA Deputy Commander for Surface Warfare (SEA 21)/Commander of Navy Regional Maintenance Centers Rear Adm. Jim Downey said
...
In that SLEP effort, we’re also looking at whether we can extend LCSs at least five more years as well.”
what for?!

OK here's the link to "capacity versus capability" considerations: Saturday at 2:55 PM
When It Comes to the Navy, Size Matters
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


"During his recent confirmation hearing, just-confirmed Secretary of the Navy Richard V. Spencer specifically
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
on the opportunity to reinforce the 350-ship goal ..."

as an armchair admiral, I noticed Jul 14, 2017
anyway what the author ignores is the White House got involved in the LCS PORK Jul 10, 2017
which may create an illusion of "capacity" while those ships are unarmed (and their "capability" is hyped EDIT as in ludicrous fantasizing: Missile Sponges & Network Nodes
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
)
 

dtulsa

Junior Member
I now read
NAVSEA: Navy Hybrid Path to 355-Ship Fleet Could Only Take 10 to 15 Years
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

and inside
what for?!

OK here's the link to "capacity versus capability" considerations: Saturday at 2:55 PM
Ok to me I'm confused they want LCS then they don't want LCS and if I were a sailor I really woul dnt like the idea of my assigned ship being refferd to as A "missile" sponge not a real secure feeling there as far as extending service life is HOW and why when they aren't even deployed yet and perhaps Jeff or someone else can answer the effects of say saltwater in aluminum as I have no idea what they are except both LCS has extensive aluminum superstructers and hulls
 
Top