Ladakh Flash Point

Status
Not open for further replies.

davidau

Senior Member
Registered Member
It's going to be very obvious if there is ever a genotype engineered bioweapon. If that is the case, China would immediately understand who and what caused it and will simply respond with the like OR if the weapon is deadly enough, with WMDs. It hopefully will not exit without taking all of Europe and the US with it BUT it needs to ensure that the suspected perpetrators are indeed the ones who executed. This is exactly the rationale behind MAD principles (discussed in the past in the BM thread) that basically make it an imperative to target and take out every major stakeholder, allies included. MAD principle is remarkably obvious and easy but clearly out of reach for some morons out there.

I imagine if the US or whichever instigator has any such grand intention for any major power (all US main competitors and would be competitors are), the targeted nation, would do everything to bring about as much MAD as it possibly can. A genotype targeting virus is fairly easy to suspect and verify. Once it is, it's all out nuclear detonation and any other weapon that's in store. If you think it takes too long to verify, before the problem gets bad, every nation would go all out offensive on suspected instigator/s before it ever gets to a stage it is too weak to do so. I believe if your theory has any truth behind it, the motivations would have been to instigate a global fallout and depopulation event with the expectation that targeted nation/s would retaliate in full. Can they hide their hand well enough though to have plausible deniability? Imagine if China unleashes a genotype bioweapon on India, India would verify it is such a thing and be totally justified in mounting an all out attack on China using nukes and whatever it wants. It would be impossible for China to create enough plausible deniability. In the real world, even if the US did the crime and blamed it on China, India would still follow through. I think that would have a higher chance of happening than China doing such a pointless thing. US wants to see China at war with others and getting bogged down. As long as it's creating obstacles for it, the Anglo US elites will throw whoever they control under the bus just to get their way.

But Xi Jinping's warning during the 100 year anniversary seems to indicate that the powers that be might suspect or know of a far greater depth of US/adversary antagonism for him to so publicly say they will crush whoever wishes to destroy China.
China does not want war, but China is not afraid of war. Proven in previous encounters.
 

Abominable

Major
Registered Member
So US, TW, Japan attacking China East while US giving orders India attack China West...

Seems more and more Covid was 100% CIA biovirus to collapse China economy and stop global travel and create the sort of artificial demand destruction so when finally US strike hot kinetic war it would lessen the global blows of supply chain disruption now that the majority of the world cannot travel and are working from home. It would also explain the mrna vaccine forced on its domestic population, perhaps America is preparing another round of biovirus this time more strategically targeting Chinese genotypes and with far deadlier fatality rates to be deployed inside China at the moment they start this WWIII.... and plus the CyberPolygon drill aka false flag in July is starkly similiar to Event 201 simulations when CIA planted biovirus in Wuhan... maybe this month the US explodes a high level EMP to knock out China power grid, then get its vassals Japan, Korea, etc to cut sea cables to China to isolate China from global internet... Then Amerikkka will also round up all ethnic Chinese in USA and gas chamber us to death in the camps..

So while China sick, blind, and deaf, in multiprong shutdown mode US will attack with vassals from all sides, and once enough Chinese nuclear deterrence is taken out, it will proceed with a full spectrum nuclear first strike on China with goal of decapituation of CPC and probably cut a backroom deal with Russia so they get to share the spoils and then sell it to the world as "it had to be done" in the name of Peak mitigation since earth had hit global peak energy back in late 2019, and with China out the way is the only hope of surviving long term climate change etc... right before they backstab russia again in cold war 3.0

Those who think USA is not this evil nor this crazy aint seen whats about to coming
That's not going to happen. I'm sure the Anglos would love one and have tried to develop one. Israel has hinted at possessing one in the past. It's possible theoretically but its unlikely a "race" virus will ever be a deployable weapon.

Infectious diseases don't tend to kill large percentages of people, if they are too "deadly" the spreaders die before they can spread it. Even if say they wanted to take out 20% of a nation and economically cripple the nation, there's a risk it would mutate and spread to non targeted populations.

Furthermore, there are too many similarities between humans. A nation/race is more than genetic factors. There's been genetic admixture in Eurasia for thousands of years now.

Finally, how would you test it?

If America or a western nation planned to wipe out a nation, they would do it with nukes, deprivation of resources, famine, and so forth. All have been tried and tested and have worked well enough in the past.
 

twineedle

Junior Member
Registered Member

Xizor

Captain
Registered Member
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!



Here is a general overview of current PLA deployments, compared to the LAC since 1962, which mostly coincides with the Indian perception with the exception of Pangong and Depsang.


A map that conveys little. This is because India and its LAC has shifted since 1962.

1.Evidence for the same at one location ( Galwan Valley) -
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!



2.At Hot Springs region, China has a camp 1 km or so into the LAC of India.

3.At Depsang Plains, China has camps well into LAC of India ( this was raised up during 2013, well before Galwan incident).
Screenshot_20210706-072139.jpg

4.At Hot Springs, beyond that camp at PP17A (labeled Gogra in Google) -

LAC likely shifted because several Patrol points that were pointed out by one Indian retired soldier doesn't seem to exist anymore.The patrol points PP19, PP18, PP20, PP21 has never been mentioned since. One must remember that LAC is usually beyond a patrol point.It's likely that adjustments from India's side similar to Galwan has happened here too.
Screenshot_20210302-060634__01__01__01.jpg


So there are three areas where India definitely has Chinese camp into LAC and one area where it is likely that a change has taken regarding what India considers LAC.
I haven't been following the past 1000 pages but could someone succinctly summarize the current border situation? (e.g. both side's status)
 
Last edited:

twineedle

Junior Member
Registered Member
This is because India and its LAC has shifted since 1962.

1.Evidence for the same at one location ( Galwan Valley) -
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!



2.At Hot Springs region, China has a camp 1 km or so into the LAC of India.

3.At Depsang Plains, China has camps well into LAC of India ( this was raised up during 2013, well before Galwan incident).
View attachment 74358

4.At Hot Springs, beyond that camp at PP17A (labeled Gogra in Google) -

LAC likely shifted because several Patrol points that were pointed out by one Indian retired soldier doesn't seem to exist anymore.The patrol points PP19, PP18, PP20, PP21 has never been mentioned since. One must remember that LAC is usually beyond a patrol point.It's likely that adjustments from India's side similar to Galwan has happened here too.
View attachment 74359


So there are three areas where India definitely has Chinese camp into LAC and one area where it is likely that a change has taken regarding what India considers LAC.
1. China does not have any camps within India's line of Patrol in Depsang. As you yourself have said, China is simply blocking Indian patrols going past the bottleneck. Similarly, India is blocking Chinese patrols, as Lt. Gen. Rakesh Sharma said in his article.

2. Once again, no reputable source has mentioned any points past 17 as being standoff points. I have even provided a map of the LAC by Lt. Gen. HS Panag that contradicts your interpretation of of Shukla's claims. Lt. Gen. Panag's maps also confirm that the current LAC at Galwan and Hot Springs is in line with India's perception, and that aside from the disputed area of Gogra/CK, with only one PLA camp, PLA does not have a permanent presence withing the Indian perception of the LAC. This is despite China's unsuccessful attempts to shift the LAC west at Galwan and Hot Springs. According to Panag, the only standoff points are beyond 17A(Gogra) and pp15(Near the area in the India Today recalibration article).

3. By now it should be clear that pp 17a is at CK. The post marked as Gogra is actually Hot Springs. Lt. Gen. Panag made this clear as well.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Div

Xizor

Captain
Registered Member
1. China does not have any camps within India's line of Patrol in Depsang. As you yourself have said, China is simply blocking Indian patrols going past the bottleneck. Similarly, India is blocking Chinese patrols, as Lt. Gen. Rakesh Sharma said in his article.


2. Once again, no reputable source has mentioned any points past 17 as being standoff points. I have even provided a map of the LAC by Lt. Gen. HS Panag that contradicts your interpretation of of Shukla's claims.
1. I'm not talking about "Line of Patrol". Indian patrols to where? Patrol points. Beyond the patrol points lie the India's perception of LAC.

China's LAC ( indistinguishable with Claims) lie beyond the bottleneck indeed. We've had Depsang discussion before.

2. Your map from Panang doesn't show any Patrol points. You conveniently use Patrol points provided by Ajai Shukla yet don't adhere to the maps or approximate locations he points out along with it.

Standoff or not. LAC of India lies beyond Patrol points. Until alternate locations for Patrol points are ascertained, one has to conclude that India did similar adjustment like in Galwan.
 

twineedle

Junior Member
Registered Member
1. I'm not talking about "Line of Patrol". Indian patrols to where? Patrol points. Beyond the patrol points lie the India's perception of LAC.

China's LAC ( indistinguishable with Claims) lie beyond the bottleneck indeed. We've had Depsang discussion before.

2. Your map from Panang doesn't show any Patrol points. You conveniently use Patrol points provided by Ajai Shukla yet don't adhere to the maps or approximate locations he points out along with it.

Standoff or not. LAC of India lies beyond Patrol points. Until alternate locations for Patrol points are ascertained, one has to conclude that India did similar adjustment like in Galwan.

As you yourself said, PLA camps in Depsang far predated the current standoff. The poster to whom i was replying was inquiring about the recent situation. The only thing that has changed is blockage of patrols, which has been on and off.
And no, the LAC has not shifted at Galwan, despite the PLA's failed attempts to shift it west




So now Panag isn't reliable? Is he pro Government? All the patrol points I have provided are publicly available, and do not line up with Shukla's drawing. He didn't even correctly label Gogra and Hot Springs. The drawing does not even line up with Detresfa's image.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Div

Xizor

Captain
Registered Member
As you yourself said, PLA camps in Depsang far predated the current standoff. The poster to whom i was replying was inquiring about the recent situation. The only thing that has changed is blockage of patrols, which has been on and off.

So now Panag isn't reliable? Is he pro Government? All the patrol points I have provided are publicly available.
Putting words in others mouth isn't my style. Panag hasn't accounted for the Patrol points pointed out by Ajai Shukla. He did draw out the LAC though.

You didn't provide ANY patrol points in Hot Springs. You lifted them up conveniently from Ajai Shukla.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top