Ladakh Flash Point

Status
Not open for further replies.

Xizor

Captain
Registered Member
With all due respect, you really need to learn more about South Asian history. Chandragupta Maurya, who ruled the largest empire in south Asian history, was a hindu who converted to Jainism after abdicating the throne. His grandson Ashoka converted to Buddhism to denounce and atone for the bloodshed of conquering Kaling. The Gupta dynasty that ruled most of Northern South Asia during what historians call "The Golden Age of South Asia" was also hindu. Even right before the British became a major power in South Asia, the majority of modern India was ruled by the Hindu Maratha confederacy.

But this discussion is way off topic.
Off topic indeed.

But I don't think the case you are making here - one where a Hindu Kingdom succumbing to British conquest - is to your advantage.

Atleast that's what is apparent after going through the religion flavored exchange here.
 

Xizor

Captain
Registered Member
Just read that PP-17A is going to be the next point of disengagement. I await the buffer zone demarcation ( if at all any). It's one of those regions where I'm not certain about the lay of LAC et all.

A buffer zone and locations of it would help dispel some of those apprehensions.
 

twineedle

Junior Member
Registered Member
What am i talking about? :mad:

Yes. I have talked to a lot of them, argued with them in different platform.

No, Do your own job and find yourself out. Don't ask other to do your work.

What?!! :mad::mad:
Hinduism can't even figure out what it is. In southern part of india people don't even recognize veda to be a religious book. Hindus are still poking around indus valley script.
The problem with hindus are, as soon as some big mouth stone is found they will claim it is hindu symbol. There were/are lot of folk religions that have those rituals that includes worshiping statues, earth elements, far far older than even sub continent religion. Gobe tepe found in turkey is 12k years old. Hinduism simply stole & copied it from them.
Hinduism is mishmash of jainism & other folk religion. In fact the concept of worshiping fire is from local zoroas in Iran.
Remember that time when you hindus were about to launch yourself to space when you found something you thought to be lost city of that bluish looking pide piper? Eventually only to fall on earth upside down. :rolleyes:
Buddhism originated from Hinduism? :mad:
Gautam Buddha exclusively rejected anything that was of Hinduism.
Only religion that has some form of root in Hinduism is Sikhism. Modern form of hindusm was invented by Vivekananda :mad:

No. Chandragupta Maurya never followed hinduism. If you follow the logic that his conversion doesn't matter after abdicating throne, then you have to show he ever followed Hinduism. He born as one doesn't make the cut. Chandragupta was never a hindu. Hindus are desperate to wash away their all time losing streak super natural azz whopping by every major power who did set foot in that direction. A person's faith is what he chooses it to be. What he was due to birth is irrelevant to this discussion.

That your mathematician discovered zero.
And they will always be zero until they start working there.
Aren't you so proud to tell others how many Indians working there instead in your own country?
What did you not understand there? :mad::mad:

There is no such thing as Indian hindus,as clearly stated by Dr. Ambedkar.
Hindus opposed independent india & eagerly served as servant of their British masters as part of British Raj. Even throughout Bengal their history as agent of British is well known.

As long as that part of history isn't set straight, India will continue to be what it is.
We will settle the score, but first, let's see how you do serve your British rebranded as american masters this time.
But rest assured, we will not allow 51st state of The United States here among us. :mad:

Btw, you aren't trying to get me banned with your circus, are you? Concentrate on this
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

Ain't this cute?
:rolleyes::rolleyes:
So no sources whatsoever to back up your garbage. Just what I thought. You say you were born Buddhist? Well you still know nothing about it. All sources indicate Buddha was born to. Hindu Kshatriya King. And where do you think the concepts of nirvana and samsara came from? There is no difference between Nirvana and Moksha.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

And the Mauryan Empire was ruled and created by Hindus. You still haven't provided any sources saying that Chandragupta Maurha did not rule as a Hindu. His son was also a Hindu for his entire life. Ironically, it only declined after Ashok adopted Buddhism, before being replaced by another Hindu Empire. If you have Any actual sources you wish to share instead of just trolling, than post them
 

twineedle

Junior Member
Registered Member
Just read that PP-17A is going to be the next point of disengagement. I await the buffer zone demarcation ( if at all any). It's one of those regions where I'm not certain about the lay of LAC et all.

A buffer zone and locations of it would help dispel some of those apprehensions.
PP 17a is in the Changlung Kugrang confluence, also known as the Gogra bulge. The situation there will be clear in a few days.
 

twineedle

Junior Member
Registered Member
The news article I read terms it as Gogra Post.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
From what I have heard, the term Gogra post is somewhat misleading. India does have a camp there, but the Gogra bulge refers to the campground along the area of the CK confluence where traders between India, China, and Central Asia would stay during the silk road era. So the entire CK confluence is reffered to as Gogr a or Gogr a bulge. The camp India has there is also considered Gogr a post, but it is not a permanent post like Hot Springs.
 

Xizor

Captain
Registered Member
From what I have heard, the term Gogra post is somewhat misleading. India does have a camp there, but the Gogra bulge refers to the campground along the area of the CK confluence where traders between India, China, and Central Asia would stay during the silk road era. So the entire CK confluence is reffered to as Gogr a or Gogr a bulge. The camp India has there is also considered Gogr a post, but it is not a permanent post like Hot Springs.

What you are implying is that Gogra Post refers to the general region taking in the areas of confluence, the bend of the river to the south as well as the Gogra Post itself.

There lies the question and that would be cleared by the details of disengagement in that region. The buffer zone in this region would help in identifying the areas of the clash. They might just be referring to the CK confluence ( a buffer zone here is realistic as both armies have camps too close to each other).
 

twineedle

Junior Member
Registered Member
What you are implying is that Gogra Post refers to the general region taking in the areas of confluence, the bend of the river to the south as well as the Gogra Post itself.

There lies the question and that would be cleared by the details of disengagement in that region. The buffer zone in this region would help in identifying the areas of the clash. They might just be referring to the CK confluence ( a buffer zone here is realistic as both armies have camps too close to each other).
Yes, that is what I would assume
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top