J-10 Thread III (Closed to posting)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Deino

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
Registered Member
...
Although I must apologize for not understanding the rest of the sentence...
...


Sorry for my cryptical last sentence, but since we saw the first operational J-10Bs I'm waiting for a confirmation of their serials to get confirmation what unit will operate them, that's all.

Deino
 

Franklin

Captain
The prices that I have seen is that the first production J-10 was about 28 million dollars a piece. But I suppose as the years goes by and more features and better technology is added to that plane that the price has gone up as well.

The barebone block I JF-17 is about 15 million dollars and the newly upgraded block II is between 20 to 25 million dollars a piece.

I guess the new J-10B will be well north of 50 million dollars if not 60 million a piece.
 

Pampa

New Member
Registered Member
Sorry for my cryptical last sentence, but since we saw the first operational J-10Bs I'm waiting for a confirmation of their serials to get confirmation what unit will operate them, that's all.

Deino

Now understood !!!
But sadly I can´t give you any serial of J-10B´s,
Yet ...

Best regards
 

delft

Brigadier
Would Russia allow resale of AL-31FN to Argentina, especially if J-10 comes as competition for Mig-29 or Su-30 ?
The improvement of relations with Argentina is important to Russia, much more important than the sale of J-10 or of Mig-29 with twice as many engines. Su-30 is probably too expensive for Argentina.
 

tphuang

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
VIP Professional
Registered Member
But was $37.5 million for FC-20 based on J-10A or J-10B? I thought that deal was so old, there wasn't a J-10B yet at the time. If a J-15 is $45 mill fly-away, I'd say that a foreign purchase price for J-10B should be just about that. Also, China has a very nice relationship with Pakistan.
I thought the deal was odd too. It sounded like the framework was for a customized J-10, although I'm not sure whether it's based on J-10A or J-10B. Either way, my point is that the cost of J-10 is a lot lower than people think. All this talk of J-10 being expensive on Chinese forums from 2006 has really led to such misconceptions. When you are used to getting J-7s at a lot less than $10 million, paying up to 200 million RMB for a J-10 sounds like a lot to some people.

As for how much it would cost to Argentina, I would imagine that depends on whether they are interested in J-10A or B. Certainly, export contracts would be more expensive and adding spares, training kits, missiles and such would add to the cost to.
The prices that I have seen is that the first production J-10 was about 28 million dollars a piece. But I suppose as the years goes by and more features and better technology is added to that plane that the price has gone up as well.

The barebone block I JF-17 is about 15 million dollars and the newly upgraded block II is between 20 to 25 million dollars a piece.

I guess the new J-10B will be well north of 50 million dollars if not 60 million a piece.
If J-10B's flyaway cost is 50 or 60 million a piece, it won't get a single order from PLAAF.
With more mature production technology and efficient production lines, there is no reason to think J-10A cost could go up that much. J-10B is using newer electronics, but electronic hardware have gotten smaller, better and cheaper in the past 5 years. There is no indication that J-10B cost is double of J-10A. And there is no indication of which variant Argentina would be interested in.

Would Russia allow resale of AL-31FN to Argentina, especially if J-10 comes as competition for Mig-29 or Su-30 ?
any engine related hurdles for J-10 would apply to JF-17 also. So if Argentina had the option of purchasing JF-17 before, I don't see why J-10 would be any different.
 

thunderchief

Senior Member
any engine related hurdles for J-10 would apply to JF-17 also. So if Argentina had the option of purchasing JF-17 before, I don't see why J-10 would be any different.

Technically speaking, Russia allowed resale of R-93 (from China to Pakistan), but AL-31FN could be a different matter . J-10 (A or B) is much bigger competition for Russia then JF-17 , not to mention J-11 . Also, we never saw China putting much effort to export these two aircraft, meaning they may have some kind of agreement with Russians (formal or informal ) not to do that .
 

thunderchief

Senior Member
The improvement of relations with Argentina is important to Russia, much more important than the sale of J-10 or of Mig-29 with twice as many engines. Su-30 is probably too expensive for Argentina.

IMHO, Argentina is too far away from Russia to be strategically important . Best they could hope for is good trading relations, but there is little to gain and much to lose if China starts selling their own fighters to this country .

As for Flankers being too expensive for Argentina, I would disagree, in my opinion they would be almost perfect for Argentinian needs , cost/performance wise .
 

thunderchief

Senior Member
Several J-10As from the 124. Brigade / Nanning base ...

I recall somebody once mentioned that PLAAF has color codes for nose radomes : black for mechanically steered radars, dark grey for PESA and light gray for AESA (or something like that) . Is this a fact, or just fan rumor ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top