PLA Anti-Air Missile (SAM) systems

Totoro

Major
VIP Professional
To my eyes, HQ9C and HQ20 are quite close in length.
1762956523979.png


hq11 and 20.jpg

Too bad the trucks arent the same, but they seem pretty close. If one assumed the tyres are of same size, then HQ20 container is even slightly longer than hq9c container. by approximately 10 percent. both should be cold launched missiles, unlike the hot launched hq11.
Too bad we don't even have a baseline measurement for hq11. i'd say its container 3.5 to 4 m long, but who knows.
If someone knows the exact length of truck used or dimensions of the tyres, that'd be very helpful.

What is apparent is that hq20 container is more or less 50% longer than hq11. Which doesnt translate into 50% longer missile, as hq20 is cold launched, so it doesnt occupy the same length percentage of the container as the hq11. But still, we could be looking at a 5 m to 5.5 m long missile. Which might then make the hq9c roughly 5 meters long? Important to keep in mind is that the naval HHQ9c is longer, as it has an additional booster stage, adding some 30% to missile's length. (assuming the baseline missile is the same) So that one might indeed be like 6.5 meters long, give or take. In other words, it's almost as long as the baseline HQ9B.
 

The Observer

Junior Member
Registered Member
size wise using Russian missiles as a scale:

FK-3B ≈ 9M100E
HQ-11 ≈ 9M96E
HQ-20 ≈ 9M96E2

View attachment 164438
View attachment 164439

Actually, size wise I think FK-3B is around 9M96E sized. Below is a pic of quad packed 9M96 missile on the S-400 system, right beside a 48N6 missile canister.

1762963080137.png

If we compare that with the HQ-22 pic & discount the increased spacing for FK-3B mounting solution, they're pretty much in the same ballpark size wise.

1762963196436.png
 
Top