You are entitled to your believes. I was just conveying mine. thats' it. I was not trying to convince you, as it is impossible to change someone's mind...This is not the first time I communicated my beliefs about the causality between the Korean War and the Lushun pull out with other people. You do have a good point, and I have heard feedbacks along the same lines from other people before, which means that you are not alone in your objection to my belief.
But I still hold to my belief.
With that being said, if many people disagree with you, it might be a good idea for you to re-evaluate your theories. Doesn't mean you are wrong, but mature theories may take many many revisions based on feedbacks from others. Don't jump to defend your theories as soon as someone disagrees with you. listen to what they have to say and use their feedbacks to further develop and mature your theories.