055 DDG Large Destroyer Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kejora

Junior Member
Registered Member

by78

General
A magazine scan of a Dalian unit in Hainan.

51222584556_c0a7382806_k.jpg
 

taxiya

Brigadier
Registered Member
Regarding 055 being 2.4 times of 052D in comprehensive combat efficiency, I remember reading a research paper regarding lunar landing. The researchers have 4 approaches of different mission duration, frequency of reaching moon surface, needed DV, number of launches and rendezvouses etc. Each characteristic has a scaling factor. The higher factor means the characteristic is more desired than others. They then get a score for every approach and got a winner.

PLAN would be doing the same thing to their ships. The characteristics would be cruise range, range of every type of weapon, total number of each weapon type, radar detection range, fire control channels, computer power, number of target being simultaneous tracked etc. PLAN would have scaling factors determined by their doctrine and desired fighting environment. Then each ship will get their score.
 

taxiya

Brigadier
Registered Member
Isn't this from a presentation made years ago?

Important to mention imo...
It is from a presentation by 赵登平 (Zhao Dengping): 海军使命与海军武器装备建设 in 2017 or before. The presentation was a series of "National Defense Education" drive by the government which involves most of Universities, high middle schools and SOEs. Zhao Dengping was/is in charge of PLAN equipment acquisition and development.
 

Richard Santos

Captain
Registered Member
.
Regarding 055 being 2.4 times of 052D in comprehensive combat efficiency, I remember reading a research paper regarding lunar landing. The researchers have 4 approaches of different mission duration, frequency of reaching moon surface, needed DV, number of launches and rendezvouses etc. Each characteristic has a scaling factor. The higher factor means the characteristic is more desired than others. They then get a score for every approach and got a winner.

PLAN would be doing the same thing to their ships. The characteristics would be cruise range, range of every type of weapon, total number of each weapon type, radar detection range, fire control channels, computer power, number of target being simultaneous tracked etc. PLAN would have scaling factors determined by their doctrine and desired fighting environment. Then each ship will get their score.

I remember when the United States embarked upon the fighter program that will ultimately become the F-15, the air force produced a computer analysis that said each F-15 was 730 times more effective than a Mig-21.

A Congressman quipped the Air Force budget should be drastically cut because the Air Force only needed 2 fighters, One for the East Coast, and one for the West Coast
 

plawolf

Lieutenant General
.


I remember when the United States embarked upon the fighter program that will ultimately become the F-15, the air force produced a computer analysis that said each F-15 was 730 times more effective than a Mig-21.

A Congressman quipped the Air Force budget should be drastically cut because the Air Force only needed 2 fighters, One for the East Coast, and one for the West Coast
Did someone forget their % sign? An F15 being 730% as effective as a Mig21 I can just about believe.
 

davidau

Senior Member
Registered Member
Did someone forget their % sign? An F15 being 730% as effective as a Mig21 I can just about believe.
I believe it is a load of codswallop! Besides this forum is about Type 055 DDG large Destroyer, what has it got to do with F15 v Mig 21?
 
Last edited:

Tam

Brigadier
Registered Member
Regarding 055 being 2.4 times of 052D in comprehensive combat efficiency, I remember reading a research paper regarding lunar landing. The researchers have 4 approaches of different mission duration, frequency of reaching moon surface, needed DV, number of launches and rendezvouses etc. Each characteristic has a scaling factor. The higher factor means the characteristic is more desired than others. They then get a score for every approach and got a winner.

PLAN would be doing the same thing to their ships. The characteristics would be cruise range, range of every type of weapon, total number of each weapon type, radar detection range, fire control channels, computer power, number of target being simultaneous tracked etc. PLAN would have scaling factors determined by their doctrine and desired fighting environment. Then each ship will get their score.


For me, the 055 is probably more than twice as expensive as the 052D, and somehow you need to explain that to the higher ups that it has to be more than 2X as combat effective.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top