manqiangrexue
Brigadier
I'm gonna agree to this point. China is not prepared to invade Japan. Only fight battles you are prepared for and Taiwan is the battle we are prepared for. China will likely use punitive trade measures such as banning rare earths, tourism, imports, etc... up to perhaps constructing some monster nuclear missile class and naming it Japan Slayer or something. But direct military intervention is not a sensible option for China at this point.If you guys really believe this then I have nothing else to say. Lol
All I would add is that knowing the CCP there will be zero military intervention. The only place I see China intervening militarily is in a case where they think they will lose Taiwan. That's the only case CCP will declare war and intervene. There is almost zero probability they will do so over Japan developing nukes.
However, I will disagree with this point. This is because nuclear Korea or Japan don't actually pose a threat to China because they are under a propaganist view that they must do this to survive and deter a Chinese invasion/decapitation of their countries. Since China does not actually have this intent, but has every ability to survive nuclear strikes from these small countries while delivering unsurvivable retaliation, nothing will change. Just because North Korea has nukes doesn't mean that it is equal to the US; it just means that the US won't dare invade it. Same with China; we were never going to invade these countries but did and will continue to enjoy a favorable power dynamic when interacting with them, nuclear or not.Which is why I have argued before that US presence in Asia is actually beneficial to China in some ways. It keeps south Korea and Japan in check by preventing them from.dveeloping nukes , same with Taiwan. Remember that it was the US that made Taiwan give up their secret nuclear program. Many people forget this. China could do nothing when Taiwan launch the program and it was the CIA that infiltrated Taiwans defense organisation and uncover the truth and sabotaged the program . US policy has long been non profileration irrespective of ally or not, reason Japan and South Korea despite long having the capabilities and means to easily develop nukes have si far refrain from.doing so. China by contrast has failed to stop North Korea from doing so. N.Korea did so because they dont trust china to defend them, since China's stance has since been ambiguous towards them, and neither has china been able to reassure them enough to even change their economic and political reforms needed to open up. In this case China's policy towards North Korea has been a failure to be honest..
In short, the moment the US leaves Asia , Japan and South Korea will easily develop nukes for obvious reasons since they know that's the best way they can dissuade their adversary North Korea and china who already have them..there is almost no doubt about this. So US presence acts as a stabilizing and reasuring factor ironically.
So basically, this is a moot point, and not really an issue mitigated by the US presense. The US presense itself, however, is the greatest evil facing China in Asia. For the US, it is actually on the table to get every one of its own assets in Asia as well as the assets and populations of Japan and Korea decimated if it could inflict enough damage to prevent China's rise and preserve American dominance. Japan and Korea are aggressive to China under US leadership but will be defensive on their own. In America's absense, they will gradually understand China's benevolence and drop their hostilities altogether in favor of cooperation because that is where all the fruits lie for everyone. So, there is no benefit to China from American presense in Asia; it mitigates a non-issue but adds an aggressive and desperate imperialistic evil.
Last edited:
