Mu Shu Tortilla
New Member
ramjets rely on atmospheric conditions to obtain optimal velocity, in which random air pockets of thin and dense clustered air can alter the ramjet from low low to high speed, so its launch to target is atmospheric condition dependant. while rockets retain constant velocity, without atmpospheric parameters hampering its velocity and range. its purely relied on its combustion and volume of fuel.
These are solid fuel ramjets, also called ducted rockets. The combustion chamber is grained with a solid fuel propellant that burns in the supersonic airflow of the ramjet. The article on the USAF project is not entirely correct in that the US Navy flies a solid fuel ramjet target drone, the GQM-163A. None of the issues you mention are valid, ramjets, even old ones like Talos, were not affected by atmospherics. Your contention of thin and dense air clustered together like so much tapioca is simply not true. I spent too many hours flying in the Navy to let that line slide without a challenge. Air density is dependent on the millibar curve present, temperature, humidity and altitude, but is uniform in an air mass. There are no sudden variations.
Crobato, the reason both the Navy and Air Force keep experimenting with these is their combination of high speed and great range makes them superior to conventional rocket propelled missiles. Phoenix was a Mach 5 missile with a 100nm plus range, but it was huge and heavy. Although a Tomcat could launch with six Phoenix, it could never attempt a landing with this load out. Pilots never launched with that load unless they could expend at least two in a training exercise, they were far too expensive to jettison to make landing weight. Those missiles also greatly restricted the Tomcat's turning performance.
One of the attractions of ACIMD/AIM-152 AAAM was that it was roughly the size and weight of a Sparrow yet had superior range and speed to Phoenix. It would have gone into production had the Air Force bought off on it for the F-22. A prototype is even on display at the Museum of Naval Ordinance at China Lake with the details of this program. It was a successful missile killed by budget considerations. Now it seems the Air Force is pursuing their own specialized ducted rocket ram jet missile for the F-22. Those videos of that MA-31 coming off the rail of that F/A-18 off Point Mugu should put paid to any notion that ducted rocket ramjets do not accelerate like a conventional rocket. Dude, we fire these things all the time.