I never understood this whole we are Muslim thing so we are all the same. Like Turks and Persians are supposed to be the same as gulf arabs just coz they have the same religions (and not even that considering sunni vs islam) ? Timur was Muslim of turco-mongol origin, I'm sure he got along very well with all those Islamic countries by slaughtering them. Nobody can seriously think some guy from Dagestan, Russia is the same as some guy in Indonesia just coz they are both muslim.China was doing far worse in the 1920-30s. Muslims also had quite a dominating presence against europe under the early ottoman empire. So, its not like Muslims have never been strong.
If we look at the big picture for the last several centuries. Muslim lands in the middle east was united under one Ottoman empire for a long time. Only this last century did it break up into pieces and gotten weak in the process. The geography and culture there is suitable for another reconsolidation into a more united state but it will take some time for it to happen. Middle East is now going through its own century of humiliation but that could be the catalyst that creates the right mindset and leadership to get more united and focused on development. Essentially this is modernisation by foreign humiliation
Aside from being different ethnically, turkey also has the advantage of being next to Europe and being part of Nato. They are also more secular. How they act and think will obviously be different from other places in the middle east.
One of the reasons I think Israel has a huge advantage is a lot of them are not really middle eastern but Europeans who claim to be related to it. So how they think and act is based on more modern trends that gives a huge advantage in effectiveness.
We have internet and loads of other information now. People are gonna start asking questions like why should I be considered the same as that person thousands of miles away who looks and acts different just coz we have the same god? I remember 10 years ago, we had right wingers on the internet saying they are all white. Today? They say he's germanic, med, slav etc.
Last edited: