China's SCS Strategy Thread

sndef888

Captain
Registered Member
I think this incident sets a pretty striking precedent. It shows the world that China is willing to use force against a US treaty ally, and doesn't face much consequence in doing so. Anyone else notice that the US is pretty quiet about this?

Also sends a message that Philippines is on their own if shit hits the fan, despite all the hoohaa about the kangaroo court arbitration just a couple days ago
 
Last edited:

votran

Junior Member
Registered Member
I think this incident sets a pretty striking precedent. It shows the world that China is willing to use force against a US treaty ally, and doesn't face much consequence in doing so. Anyone else notice that the US is pretty quiet about this?

Also sends a message that Philippines is on their own if shit hits the fan, despite all the hoohaa about the kangaroo court arbitration just a couple days ago
stick fighting isn't really count as "willing to use force" in today standard . china did that before with india who have nuclear weapon ...the fight even more serious than this (soldiers die both side)

india china no guns treaty exist for a reason ...so ...yeah guns fire matter that the minimum requirement for "willing to use force"
 

Randomuser

Major
Registered Member
stick fighting isn't really count as "willing to use force" in today standard . china did that before with india who have nuclear weapon ...the fight even more serious than this (soldiers die both side)

india china no guns treaty exist for a reason ...so ...yeah guns fire matter that the minimum requirement for "willing to use force"
It barely crosses the threshold for use of force.

But maybe that's the reason. You want to use enough just to show them your position but not enough that people care. If the other guy still back off while you don't really pay much of a price since no one else cares, that's a pretty good cost to benefit ratio.

Having a few guys whack each other with sticks on boats every 6 months seems a lot more manageable than having everyone fully armed and having to be on full alert every day.
 
Last edited:
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

The latest stand-off comes after
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
warned his Philippine counterpart on Wednesday that Manila would “bear the bitter consequences” if it tried to provoke Beijing with the help of other countries.
Wang made the remark as he lodged a “strong protest” during talks with Theresa Lazaro, the Philippines’ top diplomat, in Manila over what he called an “aggressive act of ramming a Chinese law enforcement vessel” at a disputed reef in the
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
on Monday.

It was the third day Beijing has protested over
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
at Second Thomas Shoal involving a Chinese coastguard vessel and two Philippine Navy rubber boats.

In Wednesday’s meeting, Wang said bilateral relations were at a crossroads and “where to go from here requires the Philippine side to make a correct and rational choice”, according to the Chinese foreign ministry readout.

“Over the past few years, China-Philippines relations have continued to face difficulties and challenges,” Wang said, adding that Manila’s actions were “a source of disruption to regional peace and stability”.

“Facts have proven that allowing external forces to interfere, and deliberately hyping up to escalate maritime differences, will only turn oneself into a tool for others,” Wang said.

“Attempting to provoke and cause trouble with the help of countries outside the region will ultimately [mean that the Philippines will] have to bear the bitter consequences of its own actions.

“Regrettably, whenever China and the Philippines are about to engage in dialogue, certain forces in the Philippines – particularly some in the military and law enforcement agencies – deliberately create incidents to undermine its progress,” he continued.

“These individuals do not have the well-being of the Filipino people at heart. Instead, they are carrying out the agenda of external forces while pursuing their own personal gains.”

Wang said China had never been a security threat to the Philippines, “nor has it ever invaded or colonised the Philippines”.

He called for dialogue to address their maritime disputes and urged Manila to make a “correct and sensible choice” to stabilise ties.
 

Jono

Junior Member
Registered Member
wow, 100K pesos reward!
I guess the PN sailors will all put up a 'please-beat-me-up' sign on their torsos from now on.
 
Top