I appreciate your balanced approach to evaluating the proposed S-1000 deal between the Pakistan Navy and Fincantieri.
If I may ask:
1. What's the rumored cost of the S-1000 deal?
2. What's the value proposition of the S-1000 program from the PN's perspective? What capabilities will these submarines add to the PN, and why is the PN prioritizing the acquisition and development of these capabilities?
Thank you for your questions. Many of these points have been addressed previously, but since you asked, here’s a brief summary for clarity:
- Cost of the S1000 deal:
While exact figures remain unconfirmed, indications suggest the per-unit cost of the S1000 would likely be on the lower side compared to the Agosta 90B and Hangor-class submarines. This is largely because those earlier deals included ToT and local construction components, which add to overall costs. In contrast, the S1000 is expected to be built entirely in Italy without extensive ToT, reducing expenses.
That said, being a Fincantieri product, it won’t necessarily be "cheap" per ton, quality and European manufacturing standards carry a premium.
However, if Pakistan does proceed with a fleet of 6–9 units, and if recent reports of favorable Italian-Pakistani defense-industrial cooperation hold true, there’s a strong chance the pricing is strategically adjusted, possibly as part of a broader bilateral defense package
- Value proposition for the Pakistan Navy (PN):
From PN’s perspective, the S1000 fills a crucial operational gap, shallow-water and littoral warfare capabilities. For several decades, PN relied on midget submarines to fulfill this role, but with those aging legacy platforms being phased out, the S1000 is set to replace and significantly upgrade this capability.
With the Hangor-class (039B) and upgraded Agosta 90Bs handling blue-water and medium-depth operations, the S1000 adds a "light" layer optimized for coastal missions, interdiction, and possibly special operations.
Importantly, this isn’t a token capability: the S1000 is built on a mature design base (rooted in Fincantieri’s Todaro-class experience), reportedly includes full-sized torpedo tubes, and has even been discussed in the past for VLS integration.
The overall architecture, light (S1000), medium (Agosta & Hangor), and potentially heavy (future Type 41) gives PN a scalable, survivable, and regionally credible undersea posture across multiple mission sets. With local shipyards already stretched across Hangor, MILGEM, FAC(M), and auxiliary ship programs, it’s likely that the S1000s will be entirely constructed in Italy, supporting the reported 4–5 year induction timeline.
Bottom line: If this deal concludes as expected, the Pakistan Navy will significantly enhance its shallow-water capabilities, as S1000 is more than just a niche platform, it’s a key enabler for PN’s three-tiered submarine force structure, and it appears to be moving from concept to contract in a relatively short span, which reflects both operational urgency and strategic clarity.