China Flanker Thread II

Status
Not open for further replies.

RedMercury

Junior Member
My guess is that some fans really do have insider info, but they do not reveal it because they would risk getting into trouble. The moment there is a picture which they can use to say "people can see it from that photo anyway", then they can come out and say what they know. Therefore, even if we can't be sure from the photo alone, because it is blurry or whatnot, they can be confident on what they're saying.
 

HKSDU

Junior Member
Re: Latest PLAN Aircraft Carrier Info & Photos

:eek:ff

And it's simply not feasable with the current technology. If it was, then you wouldn't see the US building an all new class of carriers with manned aircraft and an all new generation of manned fighters.

And I keep hearing that China has all this technology. Where is it? They seem to copy more weapons platforms then anything else. Look at the situation they are in with the Russians. Russia does not like selling aircraft to China anymore because of how China buys a couple then reverse engineers them. Look at the J-11, a copy of the Su-27.

Now let's get back on topic! :)
My friend you are way to brainwashed in Western media. Go research some before making a hard statement. J-11 copy of Su-27, with Russia not liking it? J-11 is license built given by the Russians itself, its not illegal copy or anything. J-11B a modernized variant. China hasn't violated the agreement. Just cause China modernized the original J-11 doesn't mean they gonna sell it nor have they did and announced it as an export item. Russia not willing to sell China fighters? China hasn't approached Russia for fighters except Su-33 which was awhile ago. The Russians are being sour cause China is purchasing less these days from Russia. Israel modernizes their F-15 does that mean its illegal copy and they are gonna export them too?
 

Tomcat7742

Just Hatched
Re: Latest PLAN Aircraft Carrier Info & Photos

:roll:

Yeah and there are several articles from Russia about how China "illegally stole" the aircraft.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Next thing your going to tell me is that the Soviet Union never copied the Space Shuttle.

To hit on another one of your points, the F-15 has always been sold to Israel through Boeing Corp, or given by the United States government. Israel didn't just get a few and start building their own. They actually took some money and paid McDonnell Douglas/ Boeing to build the aircraft for them. Do some research on the F-15, you might learn something.

But I digress, lets get back on topic :)
 

ZTZ99

Banned Idiot
Re: Latest PLAN Aircraft Carrier Info & Photos

My friend you are way to brainwashed in Western media. Go research some before making a hard statement. J-11 copy of Su-27, with Russia not liking it? J-11 is license built given by the Russians itself, its not illegal copy or anything. J-11B a modernized variant. China hasn't violated the agreement. Just cause China modernized the original J-11 doesn't mean they gonna sell it nor have they did and announced it as an export item.

That is plain wrong on all counts. The J-11A is the licenced production version of the Su-27. China has already stopped production of this variant as it no longer suits their requirements. The J-11B is the unlicensed copy which Russia has been objecting to. The production of the J-11B is a DEFINITE violation of agreements between China and Russia regarding licensed production because the J-11B is not licensed. Pure and simple. I don't know why you are having such a problem about this particular system, since the Chinese military has copied many systems prior to this one.
 

A.Man

Major
Re: Latest PLAN Aircraft Carrier Info & Photos

That is plain wrong on all counts. The J-11A is the licenced production version of the Su-27. China has already stopped production of this variant as it no longer suits their requirements. The J-11B is the unlicensed copy which Russia has been objecting to. The production of the J-11B is a DEFINITE violation of agreements between China and Russia regarding licensed production because the J-11B is not licensed. Pure and simple. I don't know why you are having such a problem about this particular system, since the Chinese military has copied many systems prior to this one.

Does Russians make anything better and operational?

If China did not buy Su's, Russia would not have any fighters to sell today. It is that China saved the aviation industry of Russia. If Russia is not going to sell jet engines, 10 years from now, China will build better engines.

The United States don't blame China taking your jobs away. If it is so hard for the United States to switch the old English system to the metric, she is just giving all the future opportunities away.
 

HKSDU

Junior Member
Re: Latest PLAN Aircraft Carrier Info & Photos

That is plain wrong on all counts. The J-11A is the licenced production version of the Su-27. China has already stopped production of this variant as it no longer suits their requirements. The J-11B is the unlicensed copy which Russia has been objecting to. The production of the J-11B is a DEFINITE violation of agreements between China and Russia regarding licensed production because the J-11B is not licensed. Pure and simple. I don't know why you are having such a problem about this particular system, since the Chinese military has copied many systems prior to this one.
All my words in last post are plain wrong eh? I wrote J-11 not A or B the original designation. Su-27 license designation was J-11 not J-11A. A was to differentiate by the Chinese to distinguish the original ones manufactured. The person post I was referring to says J-11 copy of Su-27 and how Russia didn't like it. Which was wrong cause J-11 is license designation of Su-27. I have a problem when people use copy button without knowing the actual story behind it. China acquired a license to produce 200 J-11, China hasn't gone over the limit of 200. So you expect China to produce all 200 Su-27 knowing that its obsolete avionics, lack of ground capabilities? What is it illegal copy? Cause the Russia just says so, despite the contract of agreement. You say J-11B isn't license you mean it isn't using the old Russian avionics and weapons? Or it uses new materials on its airframe? Violation of agreement please explain. If by that then Israel is illegal using the F-15 that America sold them then. Other military maybe so, but license production basically means instead of being produced in Russia its produced domestically with cap limit of 200 in China.
 

tphuang

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
VIP Professional
Registered Member
Re: Latest PLAN Aircraft Carrier Info & Photos

:roll:

Yeah and there are several articles from Russia about how China "illegally stole" the aircraft.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Next thing your going to tell me is that the Soviet Union never copied the Space Shuttle.

To hit on another one of your points, the F-15 has always been sold to Israel through Boeing Corp, or given by the United States government. Israel didn't just get a few and start building their own. They actually took some money and paid McDonnell Douglas/ Boeing to build the aircraft for them. Do some research on the F-15, you might learn something.

But I digress, lets get back on topic :)
moving your post to where it belongs.

A couple of things, those articles don't proof anything, since they are just attempting to scream at the issue to make something true. Russians haven't been known to speak the truth or being objective in all the cases. So without knowing the actual contract, nobody knows who is right or wrong.

We know that China paid for ToT on Flankers and 200 units of production. And that China still hasn't hit that 200 units. They continue to get the parts for the J-11As they never finished producing, but they are using them as spare parts rather than in the new builds. Now, the question is whether or not China should be allowed to produce J-11B. I don't think China has a problem paying the Russians for continued production, but the Russian upgrades that were offered just aren't that good. And it's been a practice with all modern ToT for Chinese companies to eventually produce the parts locally after being given the license to do so. In many case, they do it illegally, but in a lot of cases they were given the proper license.

Now, the Russians are embarrassed that China thinks the upgrade they offered were terrible. So, they are throwing fits about it. But realistically speaking, China cannot sacrifice its national security just so that the Russians will feel good about themselves. And the Russians cut off engine supply to J-11s because of this issue, but that obviously has not stopped J-11B production, since WS-10A's production issue has been resolved.
 

Engineer

Major
Next thing your going to tell me is that the Soviet Union never copied the Space Shuttle.
They never did copy the Space Shuttle, as the Buran is a totally different beast. For one, the Buran is mounted on an actual rocket, not a fuel tank.

As for J-11B, only the body resembles the Su-27/Su-30. We don't know what internal modifications China has done, but we do know that avionics, engines, and materials used on the aircraft all come from China. Russia has no say with regard to these three things.
 

Red Moon

Junior Member
Now, the Russians are embarrassed that China thinks the upgrade they offered were terrible. So, they are throwing fits about it. But realistically speaking, China cannot sacrifice its national security just so that the Russians will feel good about themselves. And the Russians cut off engine supply to J-11s because of this issue, but that obviously has not stopped J-11B production, since WS-10A's production issue has been resolved.
Wasn't there an issue also of being able to use Chinese missiles and munitions? This would be a big deal for any country, but especially since, in the medium and long term, China can never be sure which way Russia will turn. Will Russia curtail supplies to China to reduce American pressure on it (as is going on with S300 delivery for Iran)? Will Russia-India relations improve to the point where it impacts on Russia-China relations? It is always better to be self-reliant on these things, even at the expense of being accused of "copying" or "stealing". In any case I am sure intelligent Russians understand this perfectly well, even though the screaming media prefers to be hysterical.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top