A
azn_cyniq
Guest
In my opinion, there is nothing wrong with K-Pop. There are many catchy K-Pop songs and I used to be a big fan of K-Pop groups like Red Velvet. However, K-Pop is essentially a subset of American popular music and hip-hop. It doesn't sound unique at all to me. Despite its popularity, I doubt it'll influence the world in any meaningful way.Sorry but all this talk over popular music still goes back to the soft power debate. Remember because Kris Wu's handlers forgot about his birthday, they changed the release date of his album to a later date to match his birthday but the dates in other markets like the US didn't change? His Asian fans went through US outlets to buy his album early and he beat the likes of Ariana Grande who released an album the same day and Lady Gaga on the charts. Asians fall into the Western mindset where Western whites buying an album is more valuable than anyone else. It doesn't matter that more people bought Kris Wu's album than Ariana Grande's.
Can K-pop do anything independent? Do K-pop artists write their own music? Can they play their own instruments beside the stereotype of Asians playing the piano? Individuals in K-pop are going to have short expiration dates especially when they grow out of their effeminate boy look. It's going to be like when I once glanced into a nail saloon and saw a middle-aged immigrant looking Asian man doing a young white woman's nails. There was something wrong with that. These K-pop stars are going to be has-beens really quick. K-pop is a corporate controlled concoction. There is no independent music scene in South Korea. That's why you'll see suicides because they'll be replaced easily and quickly.
Every time I see these soft power debates come up, what's wrong with those advocating that China/Asians should seek soft power? They're always putting the cart before the horse. It means they don't see the music as most important. They're just trying use music as a vehicle to be liked. And you wonder why Asians aren't successful in music? Everything about it is superficial because being liked is the only point of music to them.
On the other hand, German and Italian classical music, Russian romantic music, French impressionist music, jazz, hip-hop, rock and roll, American popular music, etc. changed the world. I hope China can make a similar contribution to the world of music. I absolutely adore Chinese 古风 music and I hope that Chinese artists can combine it with other genres like classical music, popular music, etc.