Western Rome vs Eastern Tsin Dynasty

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dynasty warrior

Just Hatched
Registered Member
You guys always talk about strong dynasty vs strong empire,such as Han dynasty vs Roman Empire.Now let's organise a new battle,weak dynasty vs weak empire,Tsin dynasty vs Western Rome,who will be the winner?

Informations of Tsin dynasty: Tsin dynasty is the next dynasty of Han dynasty.In Chinese history,Tsin dynasty is a small and weak dynasty,(Especially Eastern Tsin period).To avoid the invasions of the five ethnic groups from the north,the emperor of Tsin dynasty and the Han people fled to the southern part of China.In Tsin armies,crossbows were well-developped,they had some long-ranged crossbows.Tsin's soldiers used spears and halberds against the ethnic groups' strong cavalries.Unlike the Han dynasty,Tsin dynasty doesn't have many cavalries.However,in the southern part of China,there were many rivers and lakes,so Tsin dynasty developped a strong navy,they had several strong warships.Tsin dynasty had many famous army generals,such as Zu Ti,Liu Kun,Liu Yu,Heng Wen,Liu Lao Zhi,etc.

Information of Western Rome: Roman empire seperated into two small empires,the Eastern Rome and the Western Rome.In 476 A.D,Western Rome was crushed by the Goth.I'm a Chinese and I don't know too much about Western Rome,this is the only information I have.Who has more informations about Western Rome?

Although Eastern Tsin dynasty is small and weak,I still think that Tsin's army will crush Roman army because Tsin had a strong army called Bei Fu army.
 

Gollevainen

Colonel
VIP Professional
Registered Member
It found in our past experiences with these "acient empire 1 vs. acient empire 2" threads, were its been prooven out that our members just cannot discuss civilized even over issues that can be supported with reasonable facts, not to mention something thats purely based on assumptions over misty argeolocical findings and even mistier old printed "facts". So therefore there's no way these sort of threads could be viable.

So all Han gnerals whirling their spears to block incomming arrows and other nonsense-enthusiast; Read the forum rules and exspecially what it says about comparison threads.

If you wish to have these mind-stroms, or wargames the proper forum is the members club room. This is for reasonable historical discussion

Thread closed.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top