The Best Defence is a Good Offence (China in the Americas)

FORBIN

Lieutenant General
Registered Member
How did you arrive at that number by counting the brigade and multiplying it by how many each brigade has HQ9?
That is unrealistic. did you ever hear of stockpile, inventory, reserve?
I bet their production is more than 16 HQ/year. That is for sure
Here is a good graphic on the missile coverage around china courtesy of in4ser
View attachment 36281

I have all the sites coordinates except some the last since 2/3 years but few.

It is a graphic useless for SAMs the best have a range of 200 km... far of 600

For TELs number yet with China special with opacity and necessary going for specials calculations with less exact numbers disponible, inventory and so a solution calculate according the number of units and TOE ( number of weapons in a units, personel also, ) in adddition look with Sat view but not easy weell see on these view a TELs of 8 - 10 m long one can confuse with a other truch and in addition the views are sometimes unclear ! worck for ships extremely difficult for ground vehicles so small.

Units to consider are Batallions not Brigades one have 2 - 5 Bns the Bn have 8 TELs and 8 reloading vehicles same TOE than Russian logic Chinese have buy S-300 and HQ-9 is comparable in additions majority of Chinese units have same size TOE than Russians.

The stockpile ofc not usefull to know number of TELs ! and the stock are always extremely difficult to know for all missiles so with China !!!

In addtition HQ-9 as i have say according SOC... 3 new Navy's Bns since 2 -3 years in Hainan but it is exceptionnal new HQ-9 replace always HQ-2 existing.
In more they are the first LR SAM in southern China the main areas are aroud Beijing, Shangai, taiwan strait and in interior, to middle around nuclears plant or others

I bet their production is more than 16 HQ/year. That is for sure
No according last sat view since about 2/ 3 years 2/3 new Bns possible some others but 16 worck max 6 Bns

BTW i know you the last posts for Type 726... your hate about Western, francaises as you say before edited... unpleasant and agressive, your propaganda Chinese always do the best in enormous qty obviously you are completley wrong and u make me laugh BTW surely others and i reply only for explain more for SAMs not for you.

So don't reply really useless ...
 
Last edited:

antiterror13

Brigadier
It really took me a lot of time to digest your post @FORBIN ... and I am still confused :rolleyes: .. I am really interested to read your views and posts as you are very knowledgeable

Do you know that Google is very good to translate ... just a suggestion
 

FORBIN

Lieutenant General
Registered Member
It really took me a lot of time to digest your post @FORBIN ... and I am still confused :rolleyes: .. I am really interested to read your views and posts as you are very knowledgeable

Do you know that Google is very good to translate ... just a suggestion
Surely understantable but ofc not easy jerky.
Google translation is not very good " and in both directions " also for Asian languages very bad and so long impossible for long text it is also here for SAMs enough difficult to explain so not easy.
 
Last edited:

antiterror13

Brigadier
Surely understantable but ofc not easy jerky.
Google translation is not very good " and in both directions " also for Asian languages very bad and so long impossible for long text it is also here for SAMs enough difficult to explain so not easy.

I would say Google is not perfect but I always find understand the meaning easily ... please try it in French and then translate to English and edit a bit
 
Top