055 DDG Large Destroyer Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

nastya1

Junior Member
Registered Member
What makes you think the video is right? Its nonsense unless we actually see a DF-17 lift off from a 055 via official Chinese military source.
I didn't say they are right but I keep seeing the media and military analyst talk out it. If you think they dont know what they talk about you are entitled.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
 

Deino

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
Registered Member
The video said the ship born version has shorter distance than the land version, and hence shorter booster?


Please take more care on such source's reliability and ask yourself how much likely is such a claim especially since all we know speaks against it and all reliable posters contradict such ideas?

IMO in any way the final reason for such a claim is fan-boyish wishful thinking in the same ways certain members once claimed, the J-20 can fly at Mach 3, are using already from day one operational WS-15 with a thrust of +240kN. :p

As such, forget it ... and probably do next a bit of research on your own like would such a monster missile fit in a VLS or not before trying to defend it with even more fantastic arguments.
 

nastya1

Junior Member
Registered Member
Please take more care on such source's reliability and ask yourself how much likely is such a claim especially since all we know speaks against it and all reliable posters contradict such ideas?

IMO in any way the final reason for such a claim is fan-boyish wishful thinking in the same ways certain members once claimed, the J-20 can fly at Mach 3, are using already from day one operational WS-15 with a thrust of +240kN. :p

As such, forget it ... and probably do next a bit of research on your own like would such a monster missile fit in a VLS or not before trying to defend it with even more fantastic arguments.
Fine, it you don't want me to talk about it. The I won't talk about it. It's your site
 

Deino

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
Registered Member
Fine, it you don't want me to talk about it. The I won't talk about it. It's your site


No, it is neither my site nor do I don't want to talk with you, but You brought forward a quite unrealistic claim, mentioned two more than suspicious sites (in fact fan-made YouTube-videos) which are or questionable reliability and credibility. You refute each and every reasonable argument with an even more strange reply ...

That's it.

It would be as if any strange commentator or fan-boy would claim China already has a secret base on moon armed with DF-51 (YES, a hyper secret weapon no-one knows, but surely an enlarged version of the DF-41) ...

come on!
 

ArslanPAF

New Member
Registered Member
Fine, it you don't want me to talk about it. The I won't talk about it. It's your site


It seems unlikely. DF-17 is ALOT larger than any missile that fits into UVLS. Perhaps you could adapt an AShBM to some form of canister and carry them on deck (even this is a long shot i think but who knows), DF-17 though seems like quite a reach to carry in a VLS system. Infact, i suspect the PN is going to follow a similar approach with Canisterized BM's on their boats as opposed to VLS based BM's.
 

by78

General
Satellite images of Jiangnan shipyard from a month ago.

50626353516_881720fd37_o.jpg

50626353696_7a421ca579_o.jpg

50625609173_e889397071_o.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top