Other Chinese 5th generation concepts ... not J-20 or FC-31


Tam

Major
Registered Member
Interesting tweet by @10969YUKIKAZE in a conversation with @mssn65, another Japanese PLA watcher. These tweeters appear to follow Weibo and other Chinese social media. Conversation is about would be proposals for China's next generation fighter being developed back earlier after the turn of the century.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!



Replying to
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

PLANの海軍ステルス艦搭載戦闘機の入札は終了しており,FC−31の3.0が飛行テストを準備しており,WS−19型エンジンの開発が順調に進み,入札に勝ったのはFC−31の衍生産物である。
Translated from Japanese by
The bid for PLAN's naval stealth fighter has been completed, FC − 31 of 3.0 is preparing for flight test, WS − The development of the 19-inch engine progressed smoothly, and it was FC that won the bid. − 31 cocoon products.

Original tweet.
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


中国ではこれまでに未成に終わったものを合わせると7種類のステルス戦闘機が開発されていたという記事
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
①成都J-20戦闘機 ②瀋陽FC-31戦闘機 ③瀋陽「雪鸮」 J-20と採用を争ったステルス戦闘機 (以下続く)
Translated from Japanese by
Article that seven types of stealth fighters have been developed in China when combined with what has been unfinished so far
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
① Chengdu J-20 fighter ② Shenyang FC-31 fighter ③ Shenyang `` Yuki-an '' Stealth fighter who competed with J-20 for adoption (followed)
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


9:01 PM · Apr 5, 2019·
 

ougoah

Senior Member
Registered Member
Seven separate types of stealth aircraft were developed?! I think there may be some translation errors. Perhaps 5 others that were on the drawing board and rejected in by their developers before prototyping. Or they mean prototypes and pre-production models.
 

H2O

Junior Member
Registered Member
Seven separate types of stealth aircraft were developed?! I think there may be some translation errors. Perhaps 5 others that were on the drawing board and rejected in by their developers before prototyping. Or they mean prototypes and pre-production models.
I'm leaning towards 7 concepts (finely detailed drawings or a model). There's no way they would spend the money on prototypes.
 

SinoSoldier

Colonel
Interesting tweet by @10969YUKIKAZE in a conversation with @mssn65, another Japanese PLA watcher. These tweeters appear to follow Weibo and other Chinese social media. Conversation is about would be proposals for China's next generation fighter being developed back earlier after the turn of the century.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!



Replying to
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

PLANの海軍ステルス艦搭載戦闘機の入札は終了しており,FC−31の3.0が飛行テストを準備しており,WS−19型エンジンの開発が順調に進み,入札に勝ったのはFC−31の衍生産物である。
Translated from Japanese by
The bid for PLAN's naval stealth fighter has been completed, FC − 31 of 3.0 is preparing for flight test, WS − The development of the 19-inch engine progressed smoothly, and it was FC that won the bid. − 31 cocoon products.

Original tweet.
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


中国ではこれまでに未成に終わったものを合わせると7種類のステルス戦闘機が開発されていたという記事
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
①成都J-20戦闘機 ②瀋陽FC-31戦闘機 ③瀋陽「雪鸮」 J-20と採用を争ったステルス戦闘機 (以下続く)
Translated from Japanese by
Article that seven types of stealth fighters have been developed in China when combined with what has been unfinished so far
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
① Chengdu J-20 fighter ② Shenyang FC-31 fighter ③ Shenyang `` Yuki-an '' Stealth fighter who competed with J-20 for adoption (followed)
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


9:01 PM · Apr 5, 2019·
How reliable is this Yukikaze guy and where are the Weibo and social media posts that his posts infer from?
 

Pika

Junior Member
Registered Member
Interesting tweet by @10969YUKIKAZE in a conversation with @mssn65, another Japanese PLA watcher. These tweeters appear to follow Weibo and other Chinese social media. Conversation is about would be proposals for China's next generation fighter being developed back earlier after the turn of the century.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!



Replying to
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

PLANの海軍ステルス艦搭載戦闘機の入札は終了しており,FC−31の3.0が飛行テストを準備しており,WS−19型エンジンの開発が順調に進み,入札に勝ったのはFC−31の衍生産物である。
Translated from Japanese by
The bid for PLAN's naval stealth fighter has been completed, FC − 31 of 3.0 is preparing for flight test, WS − The development of the 19-inch engine progressed smoothly, and it was FC that won the bid. − 31 cocoon products.

Original tweet.
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


中国ではこれまでに未成に終わったものを合わせると7種類のステルス戦闘機が開発されていたという記事
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
①成都J-20戦闘機 ②瀋陽FC-31戦闘機 ③瀋陽「雪鸮」 J-20と採用を争ったステルス戦闘機 (以下続く)
Translated from Japanese by
Article that seven types of stealth fighters have been developed in China when combined with what has been unfinished so far
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
① Chengdu J-20 fighter ② Shenyang FC-31 fighter ③ Shenyang `` Yuki-an '' Stealth fighter who competed with J-20 for adoption (followed)
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


9:01 PM · Apr 5, 2019·

Number #3. Shenyang “Yuken” (the black one in the image) is bigger/longer than the J-20. Certainly looks more maneuverable than the J-20 but less stealthy than it.
 

ougoah

Senior Member
Registered Member
Number #3. Shenyang “Yuken” (the black one in the image) is bigger/longer than the J-20. Certainly looks more maneuverable than the J-20 but less stealthy than it.
Shenyang had a triplane 5th gen... maybe never made it to full flying prototype but some of the earliest J-xx renderings showed something similar to this triplane fighter. No doubt this heavy weight lost out to CAC's J-20 eventually.
 

Tam

Major
Registered Member
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #7
How reliable is this Yukikaze guy and where are the Weibo and social media posts that his posts infer from?
Not sure if he is a he or a she. I'm not sure if he or she is Japanese or Chinese. There are a bunch of Japanese PLA bloggers and observers in Twitter in close contact with each other, and they appear to write both fluent Chinese and Japanese. Their stream of tweets can go from one language to another. Its hard to say if they're Japanese who knows Chinese much or a Chinese who knows Japanese much. But one thing for sure is that they are looking at Chinese social media, probably have their own accounts there, and then transmitting whatever they find like pictures, or various pieces of what they read, out into Twitter. They don't attribute however who they get it from Weibo and so on. In addition to all this, there appears to be some Japanese BBS or forum that talks about PLA related matters, like a Japanese language SDF. see

I don't take things directly on their word, but put it into my bag of consideration and further observation to see if further events would verify them or if they are consistent with future results.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


よく見ると、AVIC瀋陽の「雪鸮」案は「戦う妖精雪風」の世界観の産物に似ている。
Translated from Japanese by
If you look closely, AVIC Shenyang's “Yukikaze” plan resembles the world-view product of “Fighting Fairy Yukikaze”.


ELgn2IsVAAIDckY.jpeg ELgn2WkU8AAMIFd.jpeg


ELgtQ6JU0AIx_Tk.jpeg ELgtPT-UEAEjvV0.jpeg ELgtOk7U0AUU5jz.jpeg


This is a scene from the "Yukikaze" anime being referred to.

 

SinoSoldier

Colonel
Not sure if he is a he or a she. I'm not sure if he or she is Japanese or Chinese. There are a bunch of Japanese PLA bloggers and observers in Twitter in close contact with each other, and they appear to write both fluent Chinese and Japanese. Their stream of tweets can go from one language to another. Its hard to say if they're Japanese who knows Chinese much or a Chinese who knows Japanese much. But one thing for sure is that they are looking at Chinese social media, probably have their own accounts there, and then transmitting whatever they find like pictures, or various pieces of what they read, out into Twitter. They don't attribute however who they get it from Weibo and so on. In addition to all this, there appears to be some Japanese BBS or forum that talks about PLA related matters, like a Japanese language SDF. see

I don't take things directly on their word, but put it into my bag of consideration and further observation to see if further events would verify them or if they are consistent with future results.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


よく見ると、AVIC瀋陽の「雪鸮」案は「戦う妖精雪風」の世界観の産物に似ている。
Translated from Japanese by
If you look closely, AVIC Shenyang's “Yukikaze” plan resembles the world-view product of “Fighting Fairy Yukikaze”.


View attachment 55858 View attachment 55859


View attachment 55860 View attachment 55861 View attachment 55862


This is a scene from the "Yukikaze" anime being referred to.

I wouldn't hold my breath. The "J-35" or whatever it's called will probably show up sooner or later but likely won't be related to this guy's tweets.
 

PiSigma

"the engineer"
Number #3. Shenyang “Yuken” (the black one in the image) is bigger/longer than the J-20. Certainly looks more maneuverable than the J-20 but less stealthy than it.
Before the j20 there was the stealthy enlarged J10 concept. Single engine version of j20 based on J10 design from 611.

There was also the double engine J10 stealth version that morphed in j20 from 611.

Both of these are like year 2000.
 

Top