2019 India-Pakistani border clash

Status
Not open for further replies.

localizer

Colonel
Registered Member
Buddy, that was very uncalled for. Terror attacks, especially from a foreign source can really stir up emotions. I know this 1st hand and I do believe a Nation reserves the right to retaliate. But accusing China of backing terrorists is simply unacceptible.

China is a steadfast ally of the Pakistani government. China provides weapons and tech to the Pakistani military. Pakistan is a major strategic interest for China. But, barring some extreme situation, one thing China will not do is back terrorists or any kind of separatists. Arming and supporting terrorists is a very risky game since they can easily turn on anyone including China itself.
he still thinks this is reddit and he can karma whore
 

berserk

Junior Member
Registered Member
Buddy, that was very uncalled for. Terror attacks, especially from a foreign source can really stir up emotions. I know this 1st hand and I do believe a Nation reserves the right to retaliate. But accusing China of backing terrorists is simply unacceptible.

China is a steadfast ally of the Pakistani government. China provides weapons and tech to the Pakistani military. Pakistan is a major strategic interest for China. But, barring some extreme situation, one thing China will not do is back terrorists or any kind of separatists. Arming and supporting terrorists is a very risky game since they can easily turn on anyone including China itself.
China is the only one protecting Masood & no one else
 

P5678

New Member
Registered Member
Gee.
I already said that's my speculation. I did add that question mark, didn't I?
A statement can be a lie. A speculation can not. It can be wrong. It can be invalid. It can even be disputed as baseless. But how can it be a lie? What's your problem?
When people decide not listen to you, they will not listen to you
 

jatt

Junior Member
Okay lets fall with narrative as evidence.
1 we already know atleast 1 mig-21 is down regardless of how.
So Pakistan claims 2 kills and no loses. Lets give them that. 2 Migs. As ISPR claimed they shot 2 migs and 1 pilot is in custody and the 2nd is in the hospital. 2nd statement.
Prime Minister of Pakistan gives a statement right after the skirmish in the air. India has not responded yet. Fog of war. Go to 3:20 and he only mentions Migs and 2 pilots.
This is the DGISPR FEB 26-27? official statement. First statement in the fog of war. The guy who speaks to the media on behalf of the pakistani military.
For those who don't understand Urdu at 4:50 he says they have 2 shoot downs, 2 pilots captured 1 in the hospital. THIS IS A FOG OF WAR! Also ONLY JF-17 where used NO F-16s according to the Official from Pakistans military.
So what do the Pakistanis have? 1 pilot and 1 crash. So the other 2 pilots were mistakes. Fog of war. Must have been Indians but how did they end up in a Pakistani hospital?
Double check with India. 3rd statement and 1st from India. 1 mig and 1 pilot MIA. Nothing else.
After which, Pakistan says they have 1 pilot and the other pilot/s landed on the Indian side.
Second statement from India. They say they shot downed 1 F-16 and Lost a Bison. BOth on the Pakistani side. They also show the AMRAAM. If Amraam was fired an F-16 was involved. Pakistan lost something and definitely 2 pilots or 1.
Unless Indian pilots managed to sneak out of prison and the hospital in the greatest escape.

Also to add to this, you may want to note where India held its 2nd briefing. Under an open sky at night. No Modi no politicians. Something of a signal to the world watched and the people who understand other languages besides spoken.

1 Can assume from all this. Despite NOT having a floor picture. They India, has had a better picture of the air in around the border than Pakistan. AWACS, ground radar etc... Pakistan was hit more with the Fog of war.
 
Last edited:

jatt

Junior Member
Also like to NOTE that the DGISPR did not say they only used JF-17 he specifically said NO F-16s were involved.
 

AssassinsMace

Lieutenant General
I love how the focus is now on accusations Pakistan used their F-16s illegally meaning the West especially the US demands all the arms they sell around the world can only be used for defensive purposes. What more does anything that says defensive than this?
 

Equation

Lieutenant General
More lie he was going to retire as he turn 60 & as tradition in IAF at last day of the month but here something more for you plz confirm
D0oB7ogX4AATTYD

RRREEEEEAAALLLLYYY?? He was going to turn 60 this February? So they "retired" him mid-conflict? Haha Can you find a source with his birth date on it? It would be quite a coincidence...

Just out of curiosity, in India, how far can you use the word, "retire"? Did the 40 Indian soldiers "retire" on February 14th?
 

Equation

Lieutenant General
Okay lets fall with narrative as evidence.
1 we already know atleast 1 mig-21 is down regardless of how.
So Pakistan claims 2 kills and no loses. Lets give them that. 2 Migs. As ISPR claimed they shot 2 migs and 1 pilot is in custody and the 2nd is in the hospital. 2nd statement.
Prime Minister of Pakistan gives a statement right after the skirmish in the air. India has not responded yet. Fog of war. Go to 3:20 and he only mentions Migs and 2 pilots.
This is the DGISPR FEB 26-27? official statement. First statement in the fog of war. The guy who speaks to the media on behalf of the pakistani military.
For those who don't understand Urdu at 4:50 he says they have 2 shoot downs, 2 pilots captured 1 in the hospital. THIS IS A FOG OF WAR! Also ONLY JF-17 where used NO F-16s according to the Official from Pakistans military.
So what do the Pakistanis have? 1 pilot and 1 crash. So the other 2 pilots were mistakes. Fog of war. Must have been Indians but how did they end up in a Pakistani hospital?
Double check with India. 3rd statement and 1st from India. 1 mig and 1 pilot MIA. Nothing else.
After which, Pakistan says they have 1 pilot and the other pilot/s landed on the Indian side.
Second statement from India. They say they shot downed 1 F-16 and Lost a Bison. BOth on the Pakistani side. They also show the AMRAAM. If Amraam was fired an F-16 was involved. Pakistan lost something and definitely 2 pilots or 1.
Unless Indian pilots managed to sneak out of prison and the hospital in the greatest escape.

Also to add to this, you may want to note where India held its 2nd briefing. Under an open sky at night. No Modi no politicians. Something of a signal to the world watched and the people who understand other languages besides spoken.

1 Can assume from all this. Despite NOT having a floor picture. They India, has had a better picture of the air in around the border than Pakistan. AWACS, ground radar etc... Pakistan was hit more with the Fog of war.

Your logic totally broke between the sentences, "They also show the AMRAAM. If Amraam was fired an F-16 was involved." and "Pakistan lost something and definitely 2 pilots or 1."

An AMRAAM shell means an AMRAAM was fired. There is absolutely no connection between than and anything being shot down.
 

Deino

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
Registered Member
Rather than moderation I suggest locking this thread for 24 hours or until something substantive comes through the newswire. Some of the recent posts are simply pissing contest.

This thread is now closed for 24 hours due to the constant posting of unproven theories states as facts, national bias and repeated attacks against other opinions.

This is nasty, annoying and for beyond anything we will accept here. If you want to continue discussing theories as facts, then please search for other forums, but stop this BS here.

After this time and in an even new facts emerged, it will be opened again but only under strict observation and ALL be reminded. The next one who posts continues with flamebaiting/insulting other members/their nationalities and posting stuff from twitter and other social media as facts will get two weeks of free-time without SDF without any further warning.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top