This should be merged with the South China Sea dispute thread. Popeye?
This is a discussion on The situation in south china sea within the Navy forums, part of the China Defense & Military category; I dont think there is a thread about this, so i create one In the follow up of the incidents ...
.jpg)
Junior Member
I dont think there is a thread about this, so i create one
In the follow up of the incidents in the South china sea, there was a very rare demonstration in vietnam (against china).
Hundreds in Vietnam Protest Against China Involvement in Nearby Waters - WSJ.com
But the most serious responce came from the vietnamese defence minister, during the annual IISS Asia Security Summit: The Shangri-La Dialogue in singapure. He had pretty blunt words for china:
China Reassures Its Neighbors After Clashes Over Claims in South China Sea - BloombergVietnam has handled the incident with "patience," he said, adding that they "expect no repetition of similar incidents."
“We truly expect no repetition of similar incidents,” Vietnamese Defense Minister Phung Quang Thanh said today. Vietnam’s recent purchase of six Russian submarines was in part designed to “make a deterrent to those who have an intention to compromise and impair Vietnamese sovereignty,” he said.
China pledges peace in sea territorial disputes - CNN.com
Thats bold words. Do you think that vietnam, after aquiring su-27SK fighters, kilo submarines, and S-300PMU-1 SAM, is ready to confront china ???
And that not mentioning philipines, who also disputes the south china sea with china.
Moderator
This should be merged with the South China Sea dispute thread. Popeye?
Battles are won by slaughter and maneuver. The greater the general, the more he contributes in maneuver, the less he demands in slaughter.
-Winston Churchill
Super Moderator
I would suggest closing the thread. This may end up being a troll magnet. Situation could get out of control.
Junior Member
Before this thread actually close (which I hope not):
As a Chinese citizen, I actually not concerning about "whether this will evolve into a war?", not to mention "who would win?"
The both side (or "multi stackholders" of all the parties in the region, as the mainstream media says) knows it is unwise to "invite" what is called "INTERNATIONAL INTERVENE", knowing they are hard to be "clear out" once they came. The Chinese term is 请神容易送神难. (Reason 1)
The reason China is under spot light is because it is eye-catching, but don't forget the whole region got all kinds of "water diputes" among all the parties. (Vietnam got dispute with Philippine and Malaysia also).(Reason 2)
The "China maritime enforcement doing what they are doing, 'clashing' with other parties' maritime entities..." thing, I think is more like what the Russia and NATO has played, throughout all times - Russian sent plane or ship "walk" along with Nato's; Nato send plane or ship "walk" along with Russian... sometimes plane flyover carrier's overhead, sometimes subs crushed another sub... NO WAR BROKE OUT.
Before anyone starting to talk about "China is not affordable for a war" - sure, but please comment on the SANITY of other Chinese-south-sea-neighbors, to make the war brokes out.(Reason 3)
Reason 1+2+3, is my comments, that everyone including China, will play this carefully.
Last edited by Red___Sword; 06-06-2011 at 03:00 AM. Reason: typo
The Last Jedi
DO NOT open any other threads on this subject!! This subject has caused great disturbances in other forums. I will not allow that to happen here at SDF. This is the second thread on this subject I've closed.
Thread closed
bd popeye super moderator
Be sure to check out...
To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
don't forget
To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
am what I am.... 'Dat's all what I am"
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks