Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 27
Like Tree54Likes

Opportunities for Chinese soft power

This is a discussion on Opportunities for Chinese soft power within the Members' Club Room forums, part of the China Defense & Military category; I think we can all agree that China has an image problem abroad, particularly in the West. Lets leave aside ...

  1. #1
    plawolf's Avatar
    plawolf is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    3,098

    Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    I think we can all agree that China has an image problem abroad, particularly in the West. Lets leave aside for now, whether that image problem is deserved or not as I think that facet of the subject will be very polarizing and ultimately serves no real constructive purpose, and instead focus on things China can do to improve and change that image problem.

    I think there are a number of areas that China needs to do a great deal more on urgently.

    China can do is be more proactive in foreign affairs, especially in humanitarian relief missions. I think we are already seeing the first signs of this more confident and outward looking foreign policy. China's involvement in the Aden escort mission is the first and best example of this.

    But I think China needs to look beyond totally risk-free missions where it would be neigh on impossible for it's detractors to try and criticize them and distort the truth of what they are doing and also not bother so much with contribution to UN missions since the biased western media will never give China credit and will probably purposefully distort and omit China's contribution. Take the earthquake relief effort in Haiti for example. Pretty much the only coverage the western media made of China's contribution was the allegation that Chinese relief teams went to help Chinese peacekeepers in the country first, when in fact they went to help the UN headquarters first, and were the ones who recovered the head of the UN mission's body. It just so happens that the UN mission head was meeting with a delegation from the Chinese peacekeeping unit at the time the earthquake struck, so the news was twisted to make it look like the Chinese only went to Haiti to help their own.

    China needs to do this under it's own flag and with it's own people who display their origins prominently and proudly to the world.

    I read an article today on the plight of ordinary Syrians in the face of the growing civil war ravaging their country, and beyond the immediate sympathy and empathy for their plight, I cannot help but think that this is the perfect opportunity for China to step up.

    China can use its none interference policy and track record to its advantage and offer to set up humanitarian relief operations. Chinese flagged ships can directly bring in much needed food, fuel and medical supplies as well as tents, heaters, winter clothing, water treatment equipment, doctors etc and set up direct distribution centers with Red Cross and Red Crescent observes to pre-empt the charge that China is secretly helping the Syrian regime.

    A further step could be for China to undertake similar missions in countries western nations are actively engaged in military operations in. This would maximize public exposure so the western media cannot simply omit to mention the good works China is doing, and also create a stark contrast in the eyes of the rest of the world about the vastly different roles China and the West are playing on the world stage.

    So, if the French manage to pull off a stunning speedy victory in Mali, good for them. If not, and things descend into a protracted insurgency, China could consider establishing humanitarian relief mission to help with the displaced and injured civilian victims of the conflict.

    China could use the need to mount such missions as a reason to establish foreign logistical supply bases, which would be a far less threatening move than establishing military bases overseas, but which can serve the same purpose. The PLAAF can get long range logistical training by flying in supplies and personnel from time to time, and the PLAN can practice long range deployments and develop it's long range logistical support capabilities and put them to the test ferrying supplies.

    The most tricky element of this strategy would be security. The sight of Chinese soldiers on foreign soil would help the haters and bashers no end as they try and paint China's involvement as "colonialism" or other such nonsense, and the risks of getting dragged into a conflict because of a misunderstanding is too high. But neither should China leave it's personnel and property undefended for any outlaw group to attack and pillage as they please.

    Based on this, I think it would be best if China adopted to two step approach to security. The first is to actively engage and employ locals to help with the security. Make it clear to them that the Chinese are there to help them, and that it would be in their best interests to help keep the Chinese safe in turn. So it will be locals who provide the first line of defense, and they can be paid and equipped with non-lethal weapons like stunguns and bullet proof vests etc.

    If any unfortunate incidents occur and Chinese personnel are killed or taken hostage, it should be the locals who are the first to be asked to resolve the situation. So China will seek local tribal elders and the like to provide justice and abide by local laws and customs.

    The second part of the security strategy would be a small Chinese naval task group consisting of 1 x 071 LPD and a small number of escorts, who would be on station near any Chinese operation throughout the mission but their presence not be mentioned other than to say that they are on routine deployment.

    If the locals cannot resolve any incidents peacefully and have exhausted all peaceful avenues of negotiation, then and only then should a military option be considered.

    Hopefully such options would not need to be exercised, and China has tended to be able to negotiate the release of hostages without resorting to threats or the use of force, so this should be largely just long range deployment training for the PLAN, but the added option is always useful, and would be a good source of reassurance for the Chinese nationals operating in such dangerous places.

    So, I would like this threat to largely focus on these and any other opportunities for China to assert itself more on the world stage to help improve it's image, and to discussing the merits, costs and dangers of such missions.
    Bltizo, Equation, cn_habs and 1 others like this.

  2. #2
    airsuperiority is offline Banned Idiot
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Vancouver, Hong Kong
    Posts
    1,958

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    Quote Originally Posted by plawolf View Post
    I think we can all agree that China has an image problem abroad, particularly in the West. Lets leave aside for now, whether that image problem is deserved or not as I think that facet of the subject will be very polarizing and ultimately serves no real constructive purpose, and instead focus on things China can do to improve and change that image problem.

    I think there are a number of areas that China needs to do a great deal more on urgently.

    China can do is be more proactive in foreign affairs, especially in humanitarian relief missions. I think we are already seeing the first signs of this more confident and outward looking foreign policy. China's involvement in the Aden escort mission is the first and best example of this.

    But I think China needs to look beyond totally risk-free missions where it would be neigh on impossible for it's detractors to try and criticize them and distort the truth of what they are doing and also not bother so much with contribution to UN missions since the biased western media will never give China credit and will probably purposefully distort and omit China's contribution. Take the earthquake relief effort in Haiti for example. Pretty much the only coverage the western media made of China's contribution was the allegation that Chinese relief teams went to help Chinese peacekeepers in the country first, when in fact they went to help the UN headquarters first, and were the ones who recovered the head of the UN mission's body. It just so happens that the UN mission head was meeting with a delegation from the Chinese peacekeeping unit at the time the earthquake struck, so the news was twisted to make it look like the Chinese only went to Haiti to help their own.

    China needs to do this under it's own flag and with it's own people who display their origins prominently and proudly to the world.

    I read an article today on the plight of ordinary Syrians in the face of the growing civil war ravaging their country, and beyond the immediate sympathy and empathy for their plight, I cannot help but think that this is the perfect opportunity for China to step up.

    China can use its none interference policy and track record to its advantage and offer to set up humanitarian relief operations. Chinese flagged ships can directly bring in much needed food, fuel and medical supplies as well as tents, heaters, winter clothing, water treatment equipment, doctors etc and set up direct distribution centers with Red Cross and Red Crescent observes to pre-empt the charge that China is secretly helping the Syrian regime.

    A further step could be for China to undertake similar missions in countries western nations are actively engaged in military operations in. This would maximize public exposure so the western media cannot simply omit to mention the good works China is doing, and also create a stark contrast in the eyes of the rest of the world about the vastly different roles China and the West are playing on the world stage.

    So, if the French manage to pull off a stunning speedy victory in Mali, good for them. If not, and things descend into a protracted insurgency, China could consider establishing humanitarian relief mission to help with the displaced and injured civilian victims of the conflict.

    China could use the need to mount such missions as a reason to establish foreign logistical supply bases, which would be a far less threatening move than establishing military bases overseas, but which can serve the same purpose. The PLAAF can get long range logistical training by flying in supplies and personnel from time to time, and the PLAN can practice long range deployments and develop it's long range logistical support capabilities and put them to the test ferrying supplies.

    The most tricky element of this strategy would be security. The sight of Chinese soldiers on foreign soil would help the haters and bashers no end as they try and paint China's involvement as "colonialism" or other such nonsense, and the risks of getting dragged into a conflict because of a misunderstanding is too high. But neither should China leave it's personnel and property undefended for any outlaw group to attack and pillage as they please.

    Based on this, I think it would be best if China adopted to two step approach to security. The first is to actively engage and employ locals to help with the security. Make it clear to them that the Chinese are there to help them, and that it would be in their best interests to help keep the Chinese safe in turn. So it will be locals who provide the first line of defense, and they can be paid and equipped with non-lethal weapons like stunguns and bullet proof vests etc.

    If any unfortunate incidents occur and Chinese personnel are killed or taken hostage, it should be the locals who are the first to be asked to resolve the situation. So China will seek local tribal elders and the like to provide justice and abide by local laws and customs.

    The second part of the security strategy would be a small Chinese naval task group consisting of 1 x 071 LPD and a small number of escorts, who would be on station near any Chinese operation throughout the mission but their presence not be mentioned other than to say that they are on routine deployment.

    If the locals cannot resolve any incidents peacefully and have exhausted all peaceful avenues of negotiation, then and only then should a military option be considered.

    Hopefully such options would not need to be exercised, and China has tended to be able to negotiate the release of hostages without resorting to threats or the use of force, so this should be largely just long range deployment training for the PLAN, but the added option is always useful, and would be a good source of reassurance for the Chinese nationals operating in such dangerous places.

    So, I would like this threat to largely focus on these and any other opportunities for China to assert itself more on the world stage to help improve it's image, and to discussing the merits, costs and dangers of such missions.
    I had opened a thread at one time discussing Chinese soft power, which wasn't too well-received. Anyways I think 80% of the problem today is from the foreign media's bias, who will continue to spew venom even if God Himself appeared on Earth and make it clear China is God's way or Xi is the rebirth of Christ.

    While I do think what you suggested could be useful, it would take a very high profile incident such as Rwanda '94 or "Chinese sent an army to stop an army of orcs and zombies" in order to rally more popularity. I also think another issue is that most of the concentrations of Western media bias had always been on China's human rights and all those stuffs, so unless China "turns into democracy, freed all the human rights activists, abolish labor camps", we won't see China start being painted as good guys anytime soon. And same goes to economy. Until suddenly a golden age of new technological advances and patents all come out of China as original such as flying cars and time machines and teleporters, China would still be considered the copycat nation.
    Equation likes this.

  3. #3
    Franklin is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    1,221

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    All you mentioned above is useless. The sin of China in the eyes of the West is that its a independent power persueing her own interest in the world at the expense of Western influence. Unless China is willing to give up her economic, political, strategic and diplomatic interests around the world to align her policies with Western interests then no matter whatever goodwill gestures China makes it will fall short. If Chinese imports of African resources is called plundering and Chinese investment in Africa is called colonialisme then Chinese LPD's infront of other countries coast will be called a invasion !

    All the talk of human rights, democracy and humanisme is just that talk. In the end what counts in world politics is not value's but interests. There is no one set of rules that you can live by that can endear you to the West. Countries that have tried it before have gotten a raw deal. Like Muammar Khadaffi in Libya and Bashar al-Assad in Syria. They have in recent years try everything they can to get on a good footing with the West but look where that has gotten them. Because these countries despite offering the West a hand of friendship they still insist that they pursue their own interest in their own way rather than aligning them selfs with Western interests. I guess the sin of Bashar al-Assad is that he won't drop Iran and Hezbollah as allies for the sake of having better relations with the West. Another example is Russia when Russia was permanently bankrupt led by a permanently drunk Boris Jeltsin. Western Russian relations where at their best. Now that Vladimir Putin has gotten Russia back on track again tensions between Russia and the West are on the rise again.

    And China's current tensions with some of its neighbours relates mainly to territorial disputes. Goodwill gestures of the kind you mentioned will not help there either.
    Last edited by Franklin; 01-20-2013 at 06:36 PM.

  4. #4
    airsuperiority is offline Banned Idiot
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Vancouver, Hong Kong
    Posts
    1,958

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    Quote Originally Posted by Franklin View Post
    All you mentioned above is useless. The sin of China in the eyes of the West is that its a independent power persueing her own interest in the world at the expense of Western influence. Unless China is willing to give up her economic, political, strategic and diplomatic interests around the world to align her policies with Western interests then no matter whatever goodwill gestures China makes it will fall short. If Chinese imports of African resources is called plundering and Chinese investment in Africa is called colonialisme then Chinese LPD's infront of other countries coast will be called a invasion !

    All the talk of human rights, democracy and humanisme is just that talk. In the end what counts in world politics is not value's but interests. There is no one set of rules that you can live by that can endear you to the West. Countries that have tried it before have gotten a raw deal. Like Muammar Khadaffi in Libya and Bashar al-Assad in Syria. They have in recent years try everything they can to get on a good footing with the West but look where that has gotten them. Because these countries despite offering the West a hand of friendship they still insist that they pursue their own interest in their own way rather than aligning them selfs with Western interests. I guess the sin of Bashar al-Assad is that he won't drop Iran and Hezbollah as allies for the sake of having better relations with the West. Another example is Russia when Russia was permanently bankrupt led by a permanently drunk Boris Jeltsin. Western Russian relations where at their best. Now that Vladimir Putin has gotten Russia back on track again tensions between Russia and the West are rising again.

    And China's current tensions with some of its neighbours relates mainly to territorial disputes. Goodwill gestures of the kind you mentioned will not help there either.
    The media are least likely to change, but individuals and tourists visiting China would know, and where the discrepancies of information play, they would believe their own eyes more. And hot stories such as China making an official status quo as democracy are too hard to ignore. So even if it's true that in the intermediate run the media will go back to their ignorant ways, at least people can't call out "communists", "human rights abusers" like they used to do and would have to think of something more creative. And selling the perception that China is democratic and no longer have labor camps and human rights activists aren't locked up would still make China's life a bit easier than before.

  5. #5
    Franklin is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    1,221

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    Quote Originally Posted by airsuperiority View Post
    The media are least likely to change, but individuals and tourists visiting China would know, and where the discrepancies of information play, they would believe their own eyes more. And hot stories such as China making an official status quo as democracy are too hard to ignore. So even if it's true that in the intermediate run the media will go back to their ignorant ways, at least people can't call out "communists", "human rights abusers" like they used to do and would have to think of something more creative. And selling the perception that China is democratic and no longer have labor camps and human rights activists aren't locked up would still make China's life a bit easier than before.
    Vladimir Putin is democratically elected that didn't help him. Russia is no longer a Communist nation that doesn't help them either. Now its been called a mafia nation ! I'm sure they will find something on China too when everything you say where to happen. Hugo Chavez was democratically elected too and that doesn't seems to help him either. Do you know of any political prisoners in Venezuela ? In the end the problem with China is that its becoming stronger and more powerful and is being seen in the West as a threat to the West of their economy, ideals, influence and in the end dominance. Japan in the 1980's despite being a US satrap is being vilified in America because of its economic rise that is challenging the US. Now that the Japanese economy in the past 20+ years have become lethargic the vilification of Japan has stopt as well. The media in the West just like elsewhere in the world is a echo chamber of the powers to be.

    And there are also a lot of people posting on the internet who has been to China or at least claim to have been to China instead of talking about the progress in China they are complaining about unsafe food, dirty air, corrupt officials and the lacking in services. And they seems to be genuinely appalled by the situation in China. Somehow they expect China to run like Switserland.
    Last edited by Franklin; 01-20-2013 at 07:14 PM.

  6. #6
    plawolf's Avatar
    plawolf is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    3,098

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    All good points gentlemen.

    I am fully aware that China's biggest problem is the biased western media, who will omit all of China's good deeds and twist everything else to propagate their own agenda and propaganda.

    However, the problem with establishing a world-class Chinese English news service to get China's views and opinions out into the world is that it cannot be done by the Chinese government. Any media organization that has any links whatsoever with the Chinese government will be dismissed as a mouth piece propaganda outfit by the western media.

    After decades of programming and reinforcement (when was the last time any western media mentioned any Chinese paper or news station without calling it either a 'mouthpiece' or 'propaganda department'?), there is just no way any Chinese government affiliate English news service will be able to have any meaningful impact no matter how good the english and slick their programming.

    The only way such an outfit might work is if it was totally privately financed and based in HK. With the number of Chinese millionaires and billionaires increasing, there is a chance that one or a group of them might band together to found such an independent English news service, but it will take a long of investment over a prolonged period to get such an outfit started and established, and such a move might even hurt the people behind it, as Beijing will need to distance itself from the founders and not show them any preferential treatment or the western media will twist that to discredit the new station.

    When the western media cannot discredit the new station by trying link it to the Chinese government, they will no doubt try to go after the founders, knowing that if they kill off the money source before the station reaches critical mass and becomes self-sufficient, they can stillborn it.

    Now, for all the millionaires and billionaires in China, how many of them are willing to have all their operations in China not get any sort of preferential treatment, and maybe even being treated more harshly than would be normal or fair to make sure there is no hint of collusion, and also be themselves bulletproof against people digging into their past to see where their fortunes came from? Not that many I'm afraid. Such an organization can still be founded, but it's not something China can or should bank on, so in the meantime, there are other things China can do to improve its image abroad (and not just in the west or America).

    Trying to fight a media war with the western media is the wrong strategy in my view. The best way to break their deathgrip on mainstream media is to show them for what they really are. And the best way to do that is through action, not words.

    With the internet becoming ever more popular and influential a source for news, it will be harder and harder for the western media to keep their bias and agenda a secret from their audience if all China is do good deeds and the western media only badmouth them for it.

    The main target for these humanitarian missions would be the rest of the world, not the west and America.

    If China can get the Islamic world, the Arab world, the African world and the Latin American world to see first hand the good work and positive impact China is playing on the world stage, the more obvious the western media's bias and the more they will resent it. This world opinion would then feed back more widely and forcefully back into the western world as their citizens experience this when they travel abroad for work or leisure.

  7. #7
    plawolf's Avatar
    plawolf is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    3,098

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    Quote Originally Posted by airsuperiority View Post
    The media are least likely to change, but individuals and tourists visiting China would know, and where the discrepancies of information play, they would believe their own eyes more. And hot stories such as China making an official status quo as democracy are too hard to ignore. So even if it's true that in the intermediate run the media will go back to their ignorant ways, at least people can't call out "communists", "human rights abusers" like they used to do and would have to think of something more creative. And selling the perception that China is democratic and no longer have labor camps and human rights activists aren't locked up would still make China's life a bit easier than before.
    I think Franklin has hit the nail on the head. The West and America's problem with China is not democracy or human rights or whatever the flavor of the month BS grievance it claims, but rather because China is a strong and independent nation.

    The West have plenty of friends who are far more autocratic than China, who's people have far fewer freedoms and compared to who China's human rights record is the height of enlightenment. Half the regimes to fall in the Arab Spring were Western cronies, and the few that remain strong only do so because the west turn a blind eye to them gunning down protesters and throwing many more into prison and the same torture dungeons that the CIA deposited people when mere water bounding didn't work.

    China can do everything on todays China bashing list, and tomorrow the goal posts will be moved and the western media will find something else to bash China with.

    The only way that stops is if China become a vassal puppet of the west, and China accepts the west's dominance and inherent superiority totally and without question.

    Short of that, there is no placating the China haters and bashers, so China should not even try. The west at least gives the Russians some grudging respect for their grit and and resolve. That is far preferable to being a favored lap dog fighting for the west's table scraps and the odd condescending pat on the head.
    Last edited by plawolf; 01-20-2013 at 08:29 PM.

  8. #8
    AssassinsMace's Avatar
    AssassinsMace is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    5,105

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    There's one huge hurdle in the way for basically anything to happen. The Chinese lack charisma by design. I've read accounts of Chinese leaders saying if only Mao had died in the 1950s and then China wouldn't have gone through the upheaval of the cultural revolution. That says they even recognized Mao went too far. Which goes to why the leaders since have been dull and drab. They're afraid of another Mao rising so they intentional shy away from anyone with any charisma. They don't want any leader to have the power that comes with it.

    You need charisma in order to get soft power. And since the communists are afraid of letting any leader with charisma to come to the stage, it doesn't translate to the world because as a policy China chooses to be as neutral as possible around the world, thus no one can count on China to help them.

    Look at the Mali situation. You have the Western media as always trying to spin China into everything. This time somehow France and the West are made doing all the dirty work to protect Chinese interests. Yeah like that anti-China French leader that was just elected has a gun to his head forcing the French to protect Chinese interests. Normally they would say China is on the side of these Al Qaeda aligned rebels. For whatever reason they didn't use their default painting of China, the point is they can spin anything into anything. Why? Because the Chinese government even in their denials makes them as neutral and non-offensive as possible. If only China can muster the kind of angry response from fake outrage the West has when they spin these lies about how what's happening in Mali is all about Western military forces protecting Chinese interests. Bejing doesn't have the charisma to lead and that's why they always stay neutral.

  9. #9
    paintgun is offline Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Posts
    984

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    My mantra about China's soft power and constant media war with the West is always fix thing at home, improve the life of Chinese people and they will exude and magnify the soft power by themselves.

    Soft power is not always a product of the state or the government, but more often is a byproduct of the people.

  10. #10
    kyanges's Avatar
    kyanges is offline Junior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    645

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    Quote Originally Posted by plawolf View Post
    The most tricky element of this strategy would be security. The sight of Chinese soldiers on foreign soil would help the haters and bashers no end as they try and paint China's involvement as "colonialism" or other such nonsense, and the risks of getting dragged into a conflict because of a misunderstanding is too high. But neither should China leave it's personnel and property undefended for any outlaw group to attack and pillage as they please.

    Based on this, I think it would be best if China adopted to two step approach to security. The first is to actively engage and employ locals to help with the security. Make it clear to them that the Chinese are there to help them, and that it would be in their best interests to help keep the Chinese safe in turn. So it will be locals who provide the first line of defense, and they can be paid and equipped with non-lethal weapons like stunguns and bullet proof vests etc.

    If any unfortunate incidents occur and Chinese personnel are killed or taken hostage, it should be the locals who are the first to be asked to resolve the situation. So China will seek local tribal elders and the like to provide justice and abide by local laws and customs.

    The second part of the security strategy would be a small Chinese naval task group consisting of 1 x 071 LPD and a small number of escorts, who would be on station near any Chinese operation throughout the mission but their presence not be mentioned other than to say that they are on routine deployment.

    If the locals cannot resolve any incidents peacefully and have exhausted all peaceful avenues of negotiation, then and only then should a military option be considered.
    It's good that the thread has already reached the conclusion that nearly anything can be spun into nearly anything else, because, this idea (The specific quote above.) is so incredibly vulnerable to spin, I find it ironic that it's even suggested as a counter spin strategy.

    If China's paying the locals, then the obvious spin is that the Chinese are cowardly, dirty dealing scum, who use their resources to blackmail innocent foreigners with no other choice, to die for Chinese. It's too easy.

    I'm with paintgun on this. There's just no point in doing actions just for the sake of currying favor.
    Last edited by kyanges; 01-20-2013 at 11:12 PM.

  11. #11
    cn_habs's Avatar
    cn_habs is offline Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Posts
    471

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    Which ethnic group controls West's banking, law and media sectors? The Jews. If we could make some secret pact with those folks then the rest will be taken care of.

    However, OP's point of implementing a positive image of China among Arabs, Blacks and Hispanics is definitely worth trying. The important thing is to not piss off the Muslim extremists too often or else terrorist groups will be play the religion card to set up IEDs for the Chinese expatriates all over Africa as well. The kidnappings would then never end...
    Equation and bluewater2012 like this.

  12. #12
    t_co is offline Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    257

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    Quote Originally Posted by cn_habs View Post
    Which ethnic group controls West's banking, law and media sectors? The Jews. If we could make some secret pact with those folks then the rest will be taken care of.

    However, OP's point of implementing a positive image of China among Arabs, Blacks and Hispanics is definitely worth trying. The important thing is to not piss off the Muslim extremists too often or else terrorist groups will be play the religion card to set up IEDs for the Chinese expatriates all over Africa as well. The kidnappings would then never end...
    Er, I don't think there is an ethnic group that controls Western banking/law/media. However, China certainly has formed a tete a tete with banking, legal, and media interests in the West, insofar as China has made them plenty of money and influence.

    Peaceful integration of Chinese power into global structures is for the benefit of all. Unfortunately, folks like Andy Marshall at the Pentagon's Office of Threat Inflation, and Japanese right-wingers with lots to lose (e.g. Ishihara) seem hell-bent on keeping that from happening.
    Equation likes this.

  13. #13
    Equation's Avatar
    Equation is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Houston, Texas
    Posts
    5,034

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    Soft power media is what it is. It's power is soft....period. It's a popularity contest to the gullible non-inform viewers out there. To me it means nothing when China's continuing growth and steady advancement to better the lives of it's people. People in America and Europe has already taken notice of that as well. They're used to the dramatization of the media, therefore never take it whole hearted. Take the Lance Armstrong as an example, one day you are a hero and the next day you became a vile villain that embarrassed the nation (yes, he cheated, but that's not the point here) in the medias eyes. The internet provides so much avenues of approach to news and opinions that the big boys no longer has the upper hand of the matter. Look at the top newspapers and magazines are losing out to the public and cutting costs by letting go many of their editors and writers.

  14. #14
    plawolf's Avatar
    plawolf is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    3,098

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    Quote Originally Posted by kyanges View Post
    It's good that the thread has already reached the conclusion that nearly anything can be spun into nearly anything else, because, this idea (The specific quote above.) is so incredibly vulnerable to spin, I find it ironic that it's even suggested as a counter spin strategy.

    If China's paying the locals, then the obvious spin is that the Chinese are cowardly, dirty dealing scum, who use their resources to blackmail innocent foreigners with no other choice, to die for Chinese. It's too easy.

    I'm with paintgun on this. There's just no point in doing actions just for the sake of currying favor.
    While I have no doubt that there is a massive media bias against China, I so not think there is a massive determine conspiracy against China whereby every western journalist is secretly in on the game.

    For the vast majority if cases, the journalists who propergate anti-China views simply don't know any better.

    Western media almost systematically send their biggest China haters to China as their dedicated Chjns correspondents, and these guys and girls control what stories are filed on China.

    The vast majority of journalists, most of whom I believe to be fair and reasonable, simply never gets to see the real China because the only stories their colleges report out of China are yes hand picked few designed to highlight the negatives.

    Whenever mainstream western journalists have gone to China to report on special events of stories, heavyweights like John Simpson and Andrew Marr etc, the kinds of stories and the underlining tone is like night and day compared to the trash the regular China correspondents file.

    By going abroad, China can expose a great number of journalists to the real Chinese government, and I believe that at least some of them will give China a fair representation. Certainly far fairer than anything China can expect from the cretens currently based in China.

    It is no silver bullet, but it is a good start. The good that China would be doing in the world would be worth such a programme on it's own, so any positive publicity in the western press is just a bonus. The target audience, as I have already stressed, is not the west, but the locals the Chinese will be helping.
    Equation likes this.

  15. #15
    t_co is offline Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    257

    Re: Opportunities for Chinese soft power

    Quote Originally Posted by plawolf View Post
    While I have no doubt that there is a massive media bias against China, I so not think there is a massive determine conspiracy against China whereby every western journalist is secretly in on the game.

    For the vast majority if cases, the journalists who propergate anti-China views simply don't know any better.

    Western media almost systematically send their biggest China haters to China as their dedicated Chjns correspondents, and these guys and girls control what stories are filed on China.

    The vast majority of journalists, most of whom I believe to be fair and reasonable, simply never gets to see the real China because the only stories their colleges report out of China are yes hand picked few designed to highlight the negatives.

    Whenever mainstream western journalists have gone to China to report on special events of stories, heavyweights like John Simpson and Andrew Marr etc, the kinds of stories and the underlining tone is like night and day compared to the trash the regular China correspondents file.
    So here's the thing: I don't think Sinophobes get sent to China as dedicated correspondents on purpose; it's that most large media firms are run by risk-averse corporate bureaucrats. They pick people for their China bureaus who've been credentialed by the great filtering process of East Asian graduate studies programs at elite colleges, because these picks can't be criticized. Unfortunately for China, the vast majority of these programs are filled with strains of academic discourse left over from anti-communist and missionary thinking.

    Take John Pomfret as an example. The guy can really write, and he's got the right laurels hanging off his CV. Trouble is, his deepest professed love is for 'Chinese traditional culture', a nebulous concept which he (rightly or wrongly) believes the current techno-autocracy of the Party is destroying. Couple that with the missionary complex he acquired spending time in Beijing prior to Tiananmen Square (where he educated all the Chinese people he could meet on democratic ideals with the same quiet fervor that a Franciscan reserves for the Catholic scripture).

    Don't believe me? Google Rick Baum (may he rest in peace) and China-Pol, the invite-only listserv he created for academic sinologists and edited to keep a strongly anti-CCP stance. (Also, read this excellent article while you're at it: Kicked out of Chinapol)

    China should fix the root of the problem--the subtle patronization of academia, and the quiet censorship of pro-China viewpoints that goes on amidst grad students eager to please their advisors and acquire tenure--and then work from there. A few billion dollars of investment into creating those sorts of programs, coupled with helping the graduates of those programs find jobs in the consulting/think tank/academic/media wings of the punditocracy, could go a long way toward fixing China's image problems.
    Equation likes this.

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. Shashi Tharoor: Why nations should pursue "soft" power
    By airsuperiority in forum Members' Club Room
    Replies: 34
    Last Post: 05-26-2012, 07:47 AM
  2. Bluffer's Guide: Chinese Naval Power
    By planeman in forum Navy
    Replies: 27
    Last Post: 07-21-2011, 10:24 PM
  3. Replies: 7
    Last Post: 08-10-2009, 02:24 PM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •