PDA

View Full Version : PRC's anti-rioting abilities.




sumdud
12-19-2005, 11:13 PM
If you have been watching your news lately (I hope so.) and watched the events that took place as the WTO took session. (Wonder why so many people it appears to have no idea of the WTO meeting taking place in Hong Kong. Biased sample?) You would know about the riots that took place during the meetings and especially the last night of the meet (said to be mainly Koreans. Some Taiwanese were also in the riot).
If you didn't, here are some articles about the meet, courtesy to the SF Chronicle:
http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/qws/ff/qr?term=Hong+Kong+WTO&Submit=S
And here is info on the riot:

Protesters Try to Storm Hong Kong WTO Site
- By SAM CAGE, Associated Press Writer
Saturday, December 17, 2005



(12-17) 17:16 PST HONG KONG, China (AP) --


Protesters opposed to lowering trade barriers swung bamboo sticks at police Saturday and tried to storm a convention center where World Trade Organization delegates were negotiating a global accord on farming, manufacturing and services. At least 70 people were injured.


Security forces scattered the crowd with tear gas and pepper spray, and 900 people were detained after the worst street violence in Hong Kong in decades. The injured included 10 police officers.


The protesters included South Korean farmers, Southeast Asian groups and activists from the United States and Europe. They are concerned that WTO efforts to open up global markets will enrich wealthy nations at the expense of poor and developing countries.


By early Sunday, police ordered demonstrators staging a sit-in on a major road near the site to disperse and began dragging them away and loading them in buses.


"Police have now settled all these disturbances, and will continue this resolve action," said Hong Kong Police Commissioner Lee Ming Kwai.


Negotiations between the WTO's 149 member nations and territories continued inside the convention hall largely uninterrupted, chief WTO spokesman Keith Rockwell said.


Leading delegates met through the night into Sunday in hopes of reaching an agreement on a text that showed only incremental progress after nearly a week of largely fruitless talks on how to reduce trade barriers in services, manufacturing and farming.


"Today is the day," Fernando de Mateo y Venturini, Mexico's ambassador to the WTO, said early Sunday. "At least I hope there is going to be a result. That's my expectation."


The Hong Kong meeting was originally meant to produce a detailed outline for a global free trade agreement by Dec. 31, 2006. However, the European Union is refusing to open its agricultural markets any further until developing nations offer to lower their trade barriers to industrial goods and services.


Overnight talks focused on the contentious proposal to end export subsidies by 2010 — an issue that could make or break the entire gathering. Delegates discussed possibly pushing that date back to 2013, Venturini said.


"I think the time for brinkmanship is over," Rockwell said Saturday. "I think people realize now that we are in the end game and people will hopefully come forward with their bottom line positions so that we can wrap this up."


Outside the convention center on Saturday, police fired tear gas to quell hundreds of rioters, some wearing helmets and covering their faces with kerchiefs to ease the effects of the tear gas. Demonstrators bashed police with bamboo poles and used a metal barrier to ram a line of police armed with riot shields.


At one point, activists broke through police lines and came close to storming the WTO's harbor-side meeting venue. The police fought back with clubs, pepper spray and water cannons that sprayed a chemical mixture that burned the skin and eyes.


"The use of tear gas was too violent," said Elizabeth Tang of the Hong Kong People's Alliance on WTO. "Police knew lots of citizen onlookers and press were there and they didn't give any warnings beforehand."


Tang, whose group has organized marches here, said there had been some discussion about calling off Sunday's march, which was meant to be the largest so far.


"Some members may not agree to marching," Tang said.


Rockwell said the violence did not affect the delegates' work.


There was plenty left to be done, as the document was riddled with gaps and loopholes. Many key parts of the draft were in brackets, meaning they had yet to be accepted by all members in the consensus-based WTO.


Developing nations have been pushing for the elimination of European subsidies for exports, saying they undercut their farmers. But the EU has refused to specify a date for ending those subsidies.


"I'm prepared to engage with them on this subject, but not in isolation," EU trade chief Peter Mandelson said.


In a victory for West African cotton growers, the draft calls for rich nations to end export subsidies for cotton in 2006. This represents a U.S. concession to African claims that government support for farmers in rich countries is driving many poor farmers out of work.


"The cotton industry would be very, very concerned about that proposal, and I'm confident I've just given you the understatement of the afternoon," U.S. Secretary of Agriculture Mike Johanns said.


After trade deal talks collapsed at previous summits in Cancun, Mexico, and Seattle, the WTO's credibility would be dealt a serious blow if negotiators cannot reach an agreement here.


"There will be a heavy responsibility on anyone who lets this chance slip away," Rockwell quoted WTO chief Pascal Lamy as telling delegates.


URL: http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/n/a/2005/12/17/financial/f125950S46.DTL


http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/n/a/2005/12/17/financial/f125950S46.DTL&hw=Hong+Kong+WTO&sn=006&sc=647

I saw on the news that the protestors/rioters took advantage of the fences and broke off the bars to use them as weapon. Good thing I was not one of those policemen. (I believe of a total of 139 casualities, including 67 from the police. Just thinking about it makes me want to ******* :mad: :mad: . But let's not go there.)
Also some Taiwanese women claimed to have been abused by the police. (For breaking off the bars and using them as weapons.:coffee: What'd you expect?:roll: )

And this brings us into the topic: what do you think of China's anti-rioting skills and forces NOW. How are they? Are they effective?
AND BE WARNED, BUT DON'T ANY OF YOU DARE TO BRING US BACK TO 6-4-1989. WE ARE ONLY TALKING ABOUT CHINA NOW AND ANYONE TRYING TO BECOME PROVACATIVE WILL BE WARNED AND THEN BANNED.

To the KGB Corp (Admin and Mod), spray and cut this thread at wish.




darth sidious
12-19-2005, 11:57 PM
Sumdud

this is a bit off topic but but true

some times chinas poice force has a double standar for equipment

in two cases in my hometown some time ago there was a fight bewten some jap visitor and the owner of a self phone shop the jap insulteed the owner by saying how outdated the phone is and is junk in japan the thing turned into a fight the police showed up 2 hour later when the jap is preety much bashed up.

a few month later similar thing happened bewten chinese the police showed up in 15 minutes

PiSigma
12-20-2005, 12:25 AM
well.. i'm not suprised the cops showed up late for the japanese guy. he's just stupid to insult chinese people in china, it's suicide. unless it's constructive criticism. and of course a lot of chinese people just don't like japanese people.

back on topic.. the anti-riot police are local hong kong police, and using pepper spray and water hose are some standard things cops do. if you watch how south korean police handle riots, that gets nasty.

T-U-P
12-20-2005, 12:58 AM
by today's technology, that's all they can do without guns. They have the right to protect themselves if the protesters get violent yet they can kill any and have to keep the casualties to the minimum, pretty hard to do if you ask me.

pepper spray, water guns, tear gas are the standard anti-riot weapons today.

RavenWing278
12-20-2005, 01:10 AM
i dunno if you've seen on the news that there was a racism riot last week end between white and ethnic Australian's. The riots lasted a couple of days and the NSW police Riot Squads numbering ~1500 were pelted with molotov cocktails, a new footage showed 2 officers whose riot shields burst into fire after a direct hit from a molotov. they use shock battons and tasers to keep the crowd of 5000+ from breaking into surrounding suburbs
a bit offtopic but..just thought you guys might wanna be informed..=)

T-U-P
12-20-2005, 01:17 AM
i dunno if you've seen on the news that there was a racism riot last week end between white and ethnic Australian's. The riots lasted a couple of days and the NSW police Riot Squads numbering ~1500 were pelted with molotov cocktails, a new footage showed 2 officers whose riot shields burst into fire after a direct hit from a molotov. they use shock battons and tasers to keep the crowd of 5000+ from breaking into surrounding suburbs
a bit offtopic but..just thought you guys might wanna be informed..=)
the world sure is unstable these days, those French people was rioting just a few weeks ago. and now the australians (i always thought they are peaceful). who's next?
the police should wear fire-resistant armor against the molotov cocktails.

darth sidious
12-20-2005, 01:23 AM
40 cars are burned per weeek in paris during the rioting

fortunatly in china it is illegeal to own guns making the rioters and crimenals less well armed

sumdud
12-20-2005, 02:39 AM
Well, I couldn't imagine holding an invisible shield, looking ahead into a mob thrusting not just bamboo but also steel into your face.
Hope Hong Kong gets better fences next time.

Never heard about the Austrillians' riot.......

Uh.....Eh.....Er...... What do the South Korean police do?

Have you guys seen/hear about the pepper ball gun? Wonder if China will buy those? They've got to be better than tear gas.
And what the use of firearms? I mean firing blank rounds. Will the people get hurt? Will they leave? Or will they get agitated?

And what about the 4x4s and 6x6s China have now?

MIGleader
12-20-2005, 03:43 PM
a pepper gun can cause sever allergic reaction for some peiople, and alternaitve blanks (rubber, plastic) can richochet and destroy a windpipe, or break bones. but if the rioters had molotov coctails and other ieds, i wouldnt hesitate to use live ammunition.

rommel
12-21-2005, 06:08 AM
Well, in the Canadian Armed Force, every member of the infantry received a anti-rioting training to support the police's force if needed (although I never had to handle a riot)

1. We don't have pepper gun, we use tear gaz ( CS ) This gaz work well, execpt if the rioter has gas mask

2. In some severe case, we use water hose, no one can stand against a 25liter/sec pression of water

3.Non-lethal ammunition (it's not blank) is used when the rioter throw the tear gas grenade back to us. Rubber is not use since early 90's. All modern police and anti-rioting unit use PVC bullet, harder but weight much less. PVC don't break bones and are design to not ricochet

4. Anti-rioting suit was design to prevent wound from rock, steel and thing llike that, not molotov.... The visor protect pretty well and the thickness of those suit can absorb pretty well something pitch at you.

PS: Darth Sidious, you said that 40 cars was burn per week in Paris during the rioting ?? It's was actually an average of 1000 per night in Paris... You have to know that 200 cars burn regulaly in Paris each night...

darth sidious
12-21-2005, 04:51 PM
sry its not week

but rommel

a training round can still kill the target if it hits the right spot

Anti-rioting suit as also not effective aginst molotov gas bombs the rioters use

rommel
12-21-2005, 05:17 PM
Well, it's technically impossible to kill someone with a PVC bullet (those are not training bullet !!) Those bullets are not very powerful, but hurts a lot. They hurt a lot (even more than the old rubber bullet), enough to repel most rioter, but don't "kick" the target like the old rubber bullet. So except if you shoot on a baby with those thing, it won't kill.

You should read my post more carefully, I said that the suit are not design to prevent wound from molotov...

darth sidious
12-21-2005, 05:33 PM
but you do know the training round its a modifyed version of the convential bullet with reduced charge Right ?

rommel
12-21-2005, 05:47 PM
Euh... I'm confuse... training bullet ?? from where that come from ?? I don't know what's a "training" bullet... honestly, for training, we use live ammunition (the normal one)

I think that you're mistaken, non-lethal ammunition are shot in Canada by 12 gauge shotgun. Instead of putting pellets in the cartridge, we put a slug made of PVC
http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/9567/108136jy.jpg
http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/4725/108140cj.jpg

darth sidious
12-21-2005, 05:51 PM
its called a training round

it looks likes a normal bullet but has reduced powder charge and the tip is also smaller that thing is mostly for older guns like the lee enfield and the candian copy of FN rifle (forgot name)

but they still have them in china and yes they will kill!

rommel
12-21-2005, 06:06 PM
First of all, that not training round, from where this idea comes from ?? At least not from the military. Maybe the civilian call them training round, but that's weird. This is an anti-rioting PVC or rubber bullet. Since the army, at least in Canada and USA, don't use them for training, I don't know why you called them "training" bullet

2nd, this thing can only fit in caliber 12 gauge firearm, that mean shotgun or specialized anti-rioting weapon. Believe, I never saw an adaptor in our C1 and C2 stock for that... This is the bullet, this thing is insert in a 12 gauge standart bullet, so the entire round look like this...
http://img267.imageshack.us/img267/568/shotgunshell0tg.jpg

3rd, I can't understand why you say that this thing can kill, it's ridiculous, it got an average speed of 100-180m/sec, very slow compared to rifle or pistol bullet,no punch, big (about 24mm diameter)


Believe me, thoses things are non-lethal...

darth sidious
12-21-2005, 06:18 PM
read my post again the thing looks like a normal rifle bullet (most of times its rimed to fit older rifle)!!!!!!! only with reduce charge

and no that not fired from shoot guns but from regular army rifles and yes a smalll peaice of metal traveling at high speed willl kill you

the reason you have not heard about them is beacause they are old the canadian ross rifle and lee enfield alll have them

pS there are stilll some left over in china I have some caseing my self

rommel
12-21-2005, 06:31 PM
Okay, if you look on the first 2 picture I posted, you can that there's a scale on the side of the bullet, the bullet is around 3 cm length and 25mm height. The entire round is about 27mm caliber and 4cm long. Thoses bullets can only fit in a 12 gauge

This thing is not rimmed, I'm a soldier, infrantry corporal, I have trained myself many times with the anti-rioting equipment, you're not gonna tell me that this thing can fit in a rifle since thoses rifles are 7.7mm (British .303)...

These bullets are NOT travelling at high speed, 100m-180m/sec is very slow compared to pistol round (450-500m/sec) and combat rifle (850m-1250m/sec).

You are mistaken maybe with something else because thoses bullets was introduced in our inventory only about in 1990

That's what a normal rifle bullet looks like
http://img273.imageshack.us/img273/4039/xm8551hv.jpg(SS109 5.56mm NATO standart combat rifle ammo)

darth sidious
12-21-2005, 06:37 PM
think we are talking about different bullets

the rime is to fit enfield rifle ( they fire the .303 round) idea behind the bullet being that you can be wounded from useing it but not kill

the bullet was first made by the english before WWII other natons also copied the ideaand yes there are still left overs in china to day

rommel
12-21-2005, 06:42 PM
Well, you have to remember that we should talk about modern capability of anti-rioting with any decent equipment... I don't think that China will still use live ammunition against rioter... And rubber bullet exist since the 50's and the CS gas grenade exist since the 60's

darth sidious
12-21-2005, 06:48 PM
such equipment cost money some thing that can be better spend else where

water cannon should do the job better

the police in my honetown have army hand me downs including the follwoing

1 SKS rifle

2 Ak-47( smal amount)

3type 54 pistol ( large qunity)

4 some sort of smoke grenades

5 metal clubs ( most common)

plus the training rounds I talked about earlier




ps have you use the old FN rifle before heard your get sore after 2 clips on full auto

sumdud
12-21-2005, 07:23 PM
Why are you talking about training rounds? :confused:
He's talking about anti-rioting rounds.
You two are talking about 2 different subjects.

And it's dragging the topic :off:

darth sidious
12-21-2005, 07:44 PM
beacause the chinese police has them and they may be used in the future !!!

plus I also posted a list of equuipment the police has

Sumdud:
No need to argue with Rommel then.
You weren't talking about the same thing.
And how'd you know the PAP will use the training rounds?

darth sidious
12-22-2005, 12:56 AM
Sumdud

its beacause he mentoned them in the first post and I thought we were talking about the same thing


the training round have been used before and I have several of them my self
so I dont see why they cant be used in the future

when police are forced to open fire to defend them self the trainig round can be used as it usuly wounds its victim insted of killing it

sumdud
12-22-2005, 01:59 AM
Ok then.

I doubt China would really use training rounds though.
It'll propagate the good old image of a harsh, delibreate China back in you know when.
It'll work..........like rubber pellets..........
A bullet is still a bullet. If the rioters were as close as they were in Hong Kong, the protestors would get slaughtered.
And if blanks were used, and someone captures an image, it'will still make China look bad, for a few days if not forever, and it will make the anti-China bring up a BIG and unneeded gossip.

darth sidious
12-22-2005, 02:08 AM
I doubt China would really use training rounds though.
It'll propagate the good old image of a harsh, delibreate China back in you know when.
It'll work..........like rubber pellets..........
A bullet is still a bullet. If the rioters were as close as they were in Hong Kong, the protestors would get slaughtered.
And if blanks were used, and someone captures an image, it'will still make China look bad, for a few days if not forever, and it will make the anti-China bring up a BIG and unneeded gossip.

agreed

but in places where there are not many westerner to cause trouble and the rioters are a serious threat to safty they can be useful EG muslim revoult and tibet

Gollevainen
12-22-2005, 04:48 AM
To sort things out, let me tell you bit about the bullets we used...

We had three types of bullets, loading exercise bullets, blank bullets made of wood used which are used with this thing called sysäri (dont know the actual english term for it, but consider it as a condom but on top of the rifle's mouth)
And then there were the real full metal jackets...I have heard that there is so called 'rubber' bullets in biger nations to shoot against rioters, but i havent never seem them in action, nor even handeled one. I dont know wheter it kills you, if hit by these rubber rounds, but wooden blanks were told to be deathly as real ammoes, thougth with decreased range.

darth sidious
12-22-2005, 02:57 PM
the wooden bullet is similar to what I talking about except is metal to storage sake

it also fetures reduce powder charge and a smaller tip so your less likely to be killed from it